I played ROBLOX for some time, and I found their currency, ROBUX, if I recall, is garbage. The community is just as bad, full of little 7 and 8 year olds. But, we all have our own opinions. You may like the game, but I don't.
This would certainly get both communities talking, and probably in spite. Right now, the 'Minecraft VS ROBLOX' has calmed down a bit on the internet, but this would bring it right back up.
No support; would cause negativity in the ROBLOX community and the Minecraft community.
Ok so i was thinkin about some stuff to add in possible minecraft update heres my ideas Gosh, I didn't know it was an idea. I was in the suggestions forum but I didn't expect ideas.
|Hostile mobs| ok so the new mob ideas i had were
: Giants : Yes i know there is that thing were you can spawn in giant zombies but no. what i mean is it would be cool to have a giant steve 8 blocks tall and spawn in the dark forest biome ( See Biomes below) and they look like well giant steves with ripped clothes and blood red eyes with a frown lol so yeah on easy they do 3 hearts of damage per hit normal it does 4 and hardcore it does 5. Why? Why does the player need to be a mob? Sure, it's bigger, and it has red eyes, but that's it. It's just an oversized player with different eyes and clothing. Anyways, giants spawning naturally is oversuggested.
Next mob is : Goblins : so i don't think many people will like this Okay, right of the bat, if you don't thoroughly believe people will like your idea, don't post it. There's a reason you don't have confidence, and it's because somewhere in you, you know something is wrong with the thread. but here we go there 1 block tall and you can find them in abandon mine shafts they wear tatered brown clothes and a mining hat and carry stone or iron pick axes or shovels when they get killed they drop pickaxes or shovels along with 2-3 iron ore and 1-2 gold ore. Goblins? When did you get the idea this was a horror RPG with goblins and ghosts?
Next is the : Bandits : these mobs would span on roads to citys (see below) They will cary wooden bows iron swords or iron daggers (see iron daggers below) and would wear green shirts brown pants and a hood and cloak. When killed they would drop Iron swords daggers or arrows and a possible 1 gold ingot or apple Daggers -- oversuggested. Roads and/or cities -- oversuggested. Bandits and/or thieves -- oversuggested. Everything about this idea is pretty unoriginal and oversuggested.
Then we have : Fallen player : this mob is when ever you or someone else in you're world dies they become reanimated as A a zombie or B a skeleton mob they wil act just like a normal skeleton/ zombie and if will use you're tools as weapons aswell as continueing to wear you're armor if they are killed they ill drop you're or the player who it is's tools but not all of the tool you had. Why would you want to worry about YOURSELF KILLING YOU? And also, why would you want to have to hunt this down to get your tools back?
Now the last 2 : Frost blaze : the frost blaze can be found in the ice demension Most original idea ever. Ice dimension. see in later idea, it acts just like a normal blaze escept shoots ice charges and looks as if its made of ice.when killed drops ice charge and ice blaze rod. I've seen this in countless RPG mods. And that's its rightful place: in a mod.
AND #1 is : the wither dragon?? : yes this mob will be spawned by killing the ender dragon getting its egg and putting to wither skulls on soul sand andthe ender egg in the middle it would be a dragon that looks like a skeleton and has 3 heads it would should wither purple fire charges and whiter skulls off all 3 heads when killed drops 3 wither stars and a wither dragon skull Prehaps useable later heheheh 2 bosses combined? Requires ender egg? Requires 3 wither skulls? Shoots purple charges and wither heads? That is too hard. First off, you summon it with some of the, if not the most expensive items in the game only for it to most likely kill you. Second off, you're better off killing 3 wither individually than this unoriginal monstrosity.
and lats but not leat i just want to say 2 things it would be awesome for them to add blood and limb removal from the game it would make it so much more realistic and fun! Blood and limb removal would change minecraft's family friendly status.
Thanks for reading the other idea threads will come out with weapons encahntment biomes ores and other awesome stuff
Responses in bold.
This is the most unoriginal and redundant wishlist I have ever seen.
I'm not pretending i really have no life and don't know what to do with it if there was a truth or dare question that asks this, that's my answer. You not having a life is none of our concern.
THANK you for seeing it my way. It's optional, and nobody cares, because they can get it themselves or don't have a good enough computer.
Stop bringing up that crap about you not having a life. You're saying that because your thread was rejected. Yes, the suggestion is optional, but it's pointless. Even if your computer is good enough, you can just get the pack yourself instead of relying on mojang to do it for you.
So many of us wonder about one thing; why are biomes so scattered wildly? Why is there snow right next to a desert, or a jungle right next to a taiga? I think this was fixed in 1.7.
This has slowly been trying to make me form a new world-generation type; Continenta/Geological. It upholds the biome distribution rules of our current world; North is cold, Middle is warm, and south is cold again. It will also uphold another rule; all lands, at some point, are secluded by ocean. So, there should be a definitive top and bottom of the minecraft world? No thanks, this was never a thing and never will be.
The world generation will be entirely changed; instead of a blobbed biome distribution Fixed in 1.7 as stated before., the map will be in random-shaped layers. Some biomes will be blended into the same layer, but only if they are other variants [like Mega or Hilled]. The following layers will come in place;
<10.000, ocean/deep ocean only.
10.000 - 8.000, Ice plains, Ice hills, Frozen River, Ice plain Spikes, cold beach.
6.000 - 4.000, Mega Taiga, Mega Spruce Taiga, Forest, Plains, Birch Forest
4.000 - 2.000, Jungle, Swampland, Roofed Forest
2.000 - 1.000, Savannah, Plateau
1.000 - 0, Desert, Mesa Plateau. Once again, definitive top and bottom? Never was and never will.
After 0, the order just reverses.
During all the world generation layers, rivers keep spawning, and oceans are in great connected majority. Mushroom biomes are a rare occasion in oceans just like normal world generation. If this was added, oceans would be more common therefore mushroom biomes would be more common, which would take away the fun of finding a mushroom biome.
This is really vague. Yeah, I get it. WIP. But you should finish the thread before you post it. And before you say 'i didnt have enuf time bro!', you can always save it in wordpad or notepad to finish it then copy and paste it later.
The possibilities and uses are unlimited. Please give me your suggestions and additions in the comments. This is a work in progress. I shall update after some heavy research.
Also, critics aren't supposed to suggest for you, that's your job. Critics suggesting to help out is a bonus.
OK, I think it will work now. I'll try not using the same post and hopefully it won't come out as undefined but still get my point across the same way the original would have.
I kind of like this idea, but variants of already-existing mobs is a bit uncreative and unoriginal. Anyway, back to the mob itself. This might be a reasonable and interesting way to implement haste potions. That's all it really has going for it. Variants of already-existing mobs aren't creative and are quite redundant. You could put haste potion with some other mob drop, like normal spider eyes for instance. That was the only point this had, and it could easily fit in with something else. Also, it's a bit OP to be able to kill an enderman in 2 hits, don't ya think?
Minimal support; haste potions are a great idea but everything else is either redundant or overpowered.
Sorry but megabyte12345 do you have some sort of significance on this site? Or are you just one of those people who has to nit pick every little problem out of everyone's ideas. Cause all I've seen for the past while is you commenting on everyone's threads saying why they didn't post the right way or why peoples ideas wont work. And ok maaaaybe it is criticism like you say all the time but it is pretty crappy criticism. Maybe suggest how they could fix it rather then just say "you're wrong" and move on to tell the next person that they are wrong. You should be allowing creativity to flourish on these threads. Minecraft is all about creativity and hey if its a good enough idea Mojang will find a way to do it. Just cause you say it wont work doesn't mean there is no way to do it.
Sorry I had to do this on your post Genlems5Ever. Its a pretty good idea though!
I'm a critic. I am no more significant than any other member on this site. I don't know where you got that idea from that I think I am any more important than the others. I don't nitpick the problems either, I point out major flaws. Lastly, it isn't a critic's job to tell them what to suggest, that's the suggester's job. Critics just criticize, not suggest. I only suggest if I feel I have an idea for the thread that can really help it.
And I know if I say it that doesn't mean it's true. That can apply to universally any person.
Fine. lock the thread for all i care. all it is is a thread which no one understands, and I want someone to see it my way. just once. get an administrator if it's that bad. make him tell me that I requested this thread to be locked. I want a life and don't know how to get one.
Stop pretending to be sad so we will change our standpoints. It's been tried a million times, and never works. As
A weapon that I would very much like to see being added to the game is a lance. This would add the ability to have jousting competitions in Minecraft which would be a fun game to play with friends or even minigames on servers. Also they could be useful weapons to wield on horseback. My vision of a lance would be around 3 times the length of a sword (seeing as that's an average comparison for real life swords and lances). It would be cool if they were swung in a stabbing motion when used. Weapon variants are a bit oversuggested, don't ya think? This is pretty original compared to the rest though, I'll say that.
Lances would come in all the tiers that swords and tools would. The wooden lance would have a very low durability and would break instantly upon hitting another players shield (which I'll get into later). The purpose of these wooden ones would mainly be for sport jousting. In real jousting the object is to either break your lance over your opponents shield or knock them off their horse so having the wooden ones break would be true to real jousting. It would be cool if the lance had a 30%-40% chance of knocking a player off of their horse for the sake of jousting but I don't know if that is possible or not. A jousting minigame might be cool, but that's really all the lance has going for it.
The other tiers of lances would do the same amount of damage as a sword of the same tier but only when the lance is wielded on a horse. When carried without a horse it will do two hearts less of damage. The benefits of lances are their additional range as opposed to a sword.
If you want range, why not use a bow? They do way more damage than your lances, and have some pretty awesome enchantments.
A crafting recipe for the lance could look like this
Shields would also be a nice addition. They could play a role in the jousting I mentioned earlier as well as regular combat. Of course these would also come in every tier that armour comes in. Shields will gain their own slot in the character inventory. When equipped, the shield will show up on the left arm. It can be used by right clicking, much like when you right click now with a sword and you hold it sideways and sneak. Either that or it could be activated when you sneak (by pressing shift). Or, make a sword which can not only attack, but also block, just like shields.
Shields will block all damage taken but will lose durability quicker. Also, when you right click to use the shield it will reduce the speed of your movement and turning speed. These two features should be added in order to ensure people don't just sit around in a fight with their shield up. I don't know if it is possible or not but if there was a way to make it so that when a sword hits the shield, all the damage is blocked but when it hits a part that is not covered by the shield it harms the player. If the shield right clicking to put the shield in a blocking position regular damage will be taken. Also attacks can't be made by a played if they are in blocking position. When in blocking position, you will still get knocked back, but there could be a reduction to the amount. Maybe 50% of the knockback will be absorbed. With all these downsides, you might as well use a sword for blocking.
When the shield in its blocking position it should cover the bottom half of the screen to reduce vision in order to make the use of the shield a little more fair. Or, use a sword block which barely obstructs your vision.
When arrows are fired at a shield, there should be a small chance that arrows will go through them. Starting with a leather shield maybe a 1/4 chance, gold with a 1/8 chance, iron with a 1/16 chance and diamond with a 1/32 chance. Or, use a sword block.
New enchantments could be made for the shield. It can still get the ones that are used for armours but maybe add some shield specific ones such as one that will further reduce the amount of knockback you get after being hit in blocking position. Maybe one that allows you to perform a shield bash while blocking. If you're going to list enchantments, be a little more specific than that. Anyway, this shield may not be great, but a sword blocking enchantment might be pretty cool.
A crafting recipe for a shield could look like this
(Leather shields will be a single wooden block surrounded in the same pattern by leather in order to make it more realistic. This would make it similar to a Viking's shield)
Finally, this is optional, but it would be super awesome if you could use the same system for dying banners and use that on shields. That way you could add a crest to your shields. Completely optional but that would be awesome. Doesn't matter if it's optional. Nobody is going to use them because swords are much better.
Tell me what you think. And if anyone has anything negative to say or any problems with this idea they better also have a way to solve said problem. Constructive criticism is much better then just telling someone they are wrong. I'm glad you're being open about criticism
This is an extremely undefined idea. I think undefined undefined undefined is cool but annoying in the same sense. Pretty undefined if I undefined so myself.
Undefined; very undefined and undefined.
My undefined: undefined.
--EDIT--
Sorry the thing is messed up, I tried editing it and copy/pasting it back in, but it just says undefined. Nothing I can really do about it at this point.
0
Or, to prevent all this trouble they would have to go to to implement this, just keep the good ol' sword blocking.
Shields are oversuggested and pointless since we already can block and attack with swords.
No support; basically already in the game, just in a slightly different form.
0
My view on the situation?
I played ROBLOX for some time, and I found their currency, ROBUX, if I recall, is garbage. The community is just as bad, full of little 7 and 8 year olds. But, we all have our own opinions. You may like the game, but I don't.
0
No. Let me emphasize that. No.
This would certainly get both communities talking, and probably in spite. Right now, the 'Minecraft VS ROBLOX' has calmed down a bit on the internet, but this would bring it right back up.
No support; would cause negativity in the ROBLOX community and the Minecraft community.
1
Also, my little 3rd grade brother has better grammar than you, that should say something.
1
Most people are just bashing it for being a vague wishlist. While this is correct, I'm going to actually take a shot at it.
Responses in bold.
This is the most unoriginal and redundant wishlist I have ever seen.
0
"Also try Minceraft!"
"Blazes and endermen!"
"Minecraft edition!''
"Easter eggs!"
"Killed by a dragon!"
"Microjang!"
"TNT, we're dynamite!"
"Iron golems are full of irony!"
"Splash-ception!"
"Witch huts!"
"MineBusters!"
"Fanboy ridden!"
"Yarr, we're the only game to support pirate language and pirate movement!"
"OVERSIZED SPLASH!"
"Way too tiny splash!"
"We have metallic apples!"
"Nuggets you can't eat!"
"Poop-free!"
"Baby zombies riding chickens with a sword and an iron helmet!"
"The aspect of fire and the bane of the arthropods!"
"Farm with swords!"
"Sword with farms!"
"Former ruby, current emerald!"
"Lllooonnnggg!"
"Extra normal with some crazy spiced on top!"
"Planetary, worldwide, it doesn't matter!"
"Mo' Creatures and Le' Creatures!"
"Upside down Dinnerbone is just rightside up!"
"Fresh out of the oven!"
"Dragons VS Skeletons!"
"How much wood can a wood chuck chuck if a wood chuck could chuck wood?"
"Querty is a language, just like Asdf!"
"Don't forget Zxcv!"
"Pixellerific!"
"Removed herobrine 20 times over!"
"Ye see me!"
"Cacti are trash cans!"
"Glitchy!"
0
Stop bringing up that crap about you not having a life. You're saying that because your thread was rejected. Yes, the suggestion is optional, but it's pointless. Even if your computer is good enough, you can just get the pack yourself instead of relying on mojang to do it for you.
0
Responses in bold.
2
This is really vague. Yeah, I get it. WIP. But you should finish the thread before you post it. And before you say 'i didnt have enuf time bro!', you can always save it in wordpad or notepad to finish it then copy and paste it later.
Also, critics aren't supposed to suggest for you, that's your job. Critics suggesting to help out is a bonus.
1
OK, I think it will work now. I'll try not using the same post and hopefully it won't come out as undefined but still get my point across the same way the original would have.
I kind of like this idea, but variants of already-existing mobs is a bit uncreative and unoriginal. Anyway, back to the mob itself. This might be a reasonable and interesting way to implement haste potions. That's all it really has going for it. Variants of already-existing mobs aren't creative and are quite redundant. You could put haste potion with some other mob drop, like normal spider eyes for instance. That was the only point this had, and it could easily fit in with something else. Also, it's a bit OP to be able to kill an enderman in 2 hits, don't ya think?
Minimal support; haste potions are a great idea but everything else is either redundant or overpowered.
1
I'm a critic. I am no more significant than any other member on this site. I don't know where you got that idea from that I think I am any more important than the others. I don't nitpick the problems either, I point out major flaws. Lastly, it isn't a critic's job to tell them what to suggest, that's the suggester's job. Critics just criticize, not suggest. I only suggest if I feel I have an idea for the thread that can really help it.
And I know if I say it that doesn't mean it's true. That can apply to universally any person.
0
Stop pretending to be sad so we will change our standpoints. It's been tried a million times, and never works. As
said, just chill out and let the thread go. There's no need for this to continue.
2
Responses in bold.
0
How exactly is mojang supposed to know those people are your friends?
2
Sorry the thing is messed up, I tried editing it and copy/pasting it back in, but it just says undefined. Nothing I can really do about it at this point.