Minecraft Forums

Quote from HagenBraun

First the good: I like that you try to do some things differently then standard Minecraft, and I can definitely see you putting in effort with a lot of textures.

That said, your execution is lacking in a number of cases:

-In general, a lot of your textures are either too muddy or too noisy. There are a few tiling problems as well.
-You could make separate textures for the different logs instead of just recolouring one. The little extra effort is going to do a lot for atmosphere.
-The lines on the planks are unclear. I cannot make out if it is supposed to be two planks or one wood log.
-The ores are blurry and muddy, but it is good that you at least try to make each different, which is something a lot of people don't do.
-The stone texture is overly noisy and has that dark spot on the left side that stands out when it tiles.
-Gravel actually looks less like gravel than the stone texture. Why do you go for big dark spots here, and noise on the stone?
-Gold, diamond and iron are all just recoloured. Making a new texture for each would be good.
-Glowstone is just way too noisy, it stands out even in comparison to your other noisy textures.
-The stone bricks seem to have slightly different colours. This will stand out a lot in strongholds.
-The crafting equipment is what I would criticize most. They are extremely noisy, don't match your other colour, have that red trim (as well as that terrible blue lock on the chest) which just does not fit, and are just the original, boring Minecraft designs.
-The pumpkin is very muddy. You can hardly see any definition on it at all.

Well, I think you get the general idea... Lay off the noise and blur a little, and think through what you are trying to do with your textures more thoroughly. I think there is a lot of potential in this pack if you refine your technique a bit, get a clearer vision of what you want to do, and put in a little more effort. There is no need to rush your pack out just for the sake of it.