So, I've set up my modded server and I can join using my default gateway (192.168.x.x) address, but neither me or him can join using my public IP address. I've assumed this has something to do with me port forwarding incorrectly, though I'm not sure considering I have a new router and internet provider from when I last port forwarded and its now more complex than my old router/provider's port forwarding process. The image attached is what I am CURRENTLY putting in for my port forward, but I have also tried putting in my internal IP in both slots and my public IP in the external, but nothing has fixed it. Would really appreciate some help from someone on this. Thanks!