PSN:
Huh? Minecraft is for the Playstation? Firetruck Yeah!
Member Details
Ok so minecraft dungeons. They're okay. But not as cool as strongholds. Strongholds make the time you took to search for them, worth while. I mean just look at it.
Stronghold
-Has a chest in almost every room(Major loot)
-Lots of Monsters(Thrill and Experience)
-At the end of it, you get to go to a new dimension(and fight a sweet Boss!)
-And a bunch of other stuff I can't think of
Well there you have it. That's how awesome strongholds are. Now to the dungeons. You'll see how not as awesome they are compared to strongholds.
Dungeons
-Have 1 or 2 chests total(Minor loot)
-Monster spawner(Mob farm and experience)
- 1 room. Just 1 whole room.
Now you see? If I had a choice, I'd go looking for a stronghold instead of a dungeon. And the dungeon is in only 1 room. JUST ONE ROOM! I mean, look at the definition of Dungeon
dun·geon
ˈdənjən/
noun
1.
a strong underground prison cell, especially in a castle.
That's the definition. In nowhere do you see "One small room with minor loot". Here is a picture of a typical minecraft dungeon I made
That's a typical dungeon(minus the pig spawner and torch). Now my Idea is to make MORE than one room into the dungeon. Here I have built a room.
That's a long hall with traps and chests. You can mine through the wall or you can mine the iron bars.
Here is inside of it. You can see 3 dispensers and a chest way in the back if you look.
This is in dispenser 1. Potions of Weakness for 1:01 and you do 0.5 less attack damage. The second one has arrows in it but I didn't get a screen shot.
The third has, you guessed it, fire charges. Then we get the chest and find out it has...
Loot fit for a king! Next I have a mini library. I know the stronghold already has one but this is a mini one.
The library has bookcases, cobwebs, a chest, and a witch. Also there were a couple bats spawning in but that doesn't matter. Finally here is a picture of the finished stronghold outside.
The little stone things on the hall are meant to cover up the dispenser.
Well there you have it. I am finished rambling out Dungeons now and you probably never want to read something ever again but I hope my suggestion gets support and post your dungeon room ideas down in the comments. And would you hit that little green arrow in the lower right hand corner if you give support? Thank you for your time and answer the poll! It's important.
EDIT: You can get the Custom achievement right here!
It would be very cool to see more elaborate dungeons - but frankly, that's what mods are for. Not saying that Mojang shouldn't do it - I'm all for it - just saying I suspect that's what they'd say.
Being a nerd is nothing to be ashamed of. Nerds rule the world! Who invented the internet? Nerds. Who created personal computers and smart phones? Nerds. Who made every video game you've ever played and ever will? Still nerds. Who sent probes to distant planets? Nerds, nerds and more nerds! I'm a nerd and I'm proud.
It would be very cool to see more elaborate dungeons - but frankly, that's what mods are for. Not saying that Mojang shouldn't do it - I'm all for it - just saying I suspect that's what they'd say.
I didn't mean for Mojang to fully on update dungeons, but it would be nice if they added a new room or something. Maybe a second spawner or something to make dungeons better. They're just a little plain and boring. Not in a "Plain and boring way so let's make a better dungeon mod" but in a way so that just give dungeons a little kick
The dungeon is supposed to be nothing more then a small room. Of course Minecraft's dungeons were upgraded over the course of time, by adding new dungeons and structures (Jungle/Desert temples, strongholds and Ocean monuments). That's the way it should stay, In my opinion. Keep the small little dungens we have, and occasionally add some new structures with loot and puzzles.
Being a nerd is nothing to be ashamed of. Nerds rule the world! Who invented the internet? Nerds. Who created personal computers and smart phones? Nerds. Who made every video game you've ever played and ever will? Still nerds. Who sent probes to distant planets? Nerds, nerds and more nerds! I'm a nerd and I'm proud.
The dungeon is supposed to be nothing more then a small room. Of course Minecraft's dungeons were upgraded over the course of time, by adding new dungeons and structures (Jungle/Desert temples, strongholds and Ocean monuments). That's the way it should stay, In my opinion. Keep the small little dungens we have, and occasionally add some new structures with loot and puzzles.
Yes but if Mojang doesn't occasionally update Dungeons they'll be long and forgotten so when new players(or old ones who haven't played in a while) will find a dungeon and be like "Hey I found a new structure they must have added!' then they take a screenshot, post it here on the forums, then finally someone breaks it to them and says "Nope sorry, that's an old structure called a dungeon but Mojang didn't keep updating it so it's rare to find one". Then eventually Mojang could realize they haven't updated it then just remove the dungeon itself completely from the game and I'm one of the people that's doesn't want this to happen. That's why I want Mojang to update Dungeons.
This is a pretty cool suggestion, but people will mine the dungeon's walls to get whats in the dispenser and to get all the loot.
Maybe we add something like obsidian to block the dispensers but that'll just raise suspicion to finding the dungeon. So I'll keep trying and experimenting.
Being a nerd is nothing to be ashamed of. Nerds rule the world! Who invented the internet? Nerds. Who created personal computers and smart phones? Nerds. Who made every video game you've ever played and ever will? Still nerds. Who sent probes to distant planets? Nerds, nerds and more nerds! I'm a nerd and I'm proud.
There are only 3 strongholds in every Minecraft world. They're very rare so they should contain rare and cool stuff.
There are an infinite number of dungeons in every Minecraft world. If they all contained super rare stuff like End Portals, it would be very overpowered. While it would be neat if they were updated to be more than a tiny box, I don't support any HUGE overhaul.
There are only 3 strongholds in every Minecraft world. They're very rare so they should contain rare and cool stuff.
There are an infinite number of dungeons in every Minecraft world. If they all contained super rare stuff like End Portals, it would be very overpowered. While it would be neat if they were updated to be more than a tiny box, I don't support any HUGE overhaul.
Dungeons aren't infinite , so as the Minecraft world , it is 30.000.000 blocks wide . but that's enough to find billions of dungeons ...
Being a nerd is nothing to be ashamed of. Nerds rule the world! Who invented the internet? Nerds. Who created personal computers and smart phones? Nerds. Who made every video game you've ever played and ever will? Still nerds. Who sent probes to distant planets? Nerds, nerds and more nerds! I'm a nerd and I'm proud.
Dungeons aren't infinite , so as the Minecraft world , it is 30.000.000 blocks wide . but that's enough to find billions of dungeons ...
True, and we didn't need too many of it
Dungeons should be what it be, if the dungeon gets upgraded and became more bigger, then miners would be easy to find it. And loot everything that he find (even the walls)
This is an interesting concept. I think upgrading what we know as dungeons into actual "dungeons" would make dungeon-hunting a more valuable and worthwhile profession, but I don't see it on the top of the priorities list. For example, I'd like to see more biomes before I see improved dungeons, but it would definitely be nice! The loot should be slightly nerfed, for example you shouldn't be able to find a nice powerful sword and diamonds and emeralds and enchanted books; thats what the rare and exciting strongholds are for. However, I don't feel content walking into a dungeon and receiving two saddles and a Power II book, either.
Overall, an interesting concept. Maybe a bit of tweaking on the loot, but besides that I like the idea and the size of it. I'll give a 75% Support on this one.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I need my beautiful little egg to grow up, so please, feed it those tasty clicks! Also, regarding the adults, they'll click you.
Dungeons should be what it be, if the dungeon gets upgraded and became more bigger, then miners would be easy to find it. And loot everything that he find (even the walls)
No Support
Ok , then Dungeons should be kept the way they are , make them a little bit rarer , and add the big dungeons . with the same chance of spawning as desert temples but underground .
Being a nerd is nothing to be ashamed of. Nerds rule the world! Who invented the internet? Nerds. Who created personal computers and smart phones? Nerds. Who made every video game you've ever played and ever will? Still nerds. Who sent probes to distant planets? Nerds, nerds and more nerds! I'm a nerd and I'm proud.
That seems fair! What's on the sword, out of curiosity? And maybe multiple chests like that. There could be one chest in the dungeon that has a couple of rare diamonds or iron, but not in every chest. But it's improved now, good job!
Full Support :D.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I need my beautiful little egg to grow up, so please, feed it those tasty clicks! Also, regarding the adults, they'll click you.
That seems fair! What's on the sword, out of curiosity? And maybe multiple chests like that. There could be one chest in the dungeon that has a couple of rare diamonds or iron, but not in every chest. But it's improved now, good job!
Dungeons should be what it be, if the dungeon gets upgraded and became more bigger, then miners would be easy to find it. And loot everything that he find (even the walls)
No Support
I'm not saying to majorly update it. Just add a room or 2. The Library might not even happen I wasn't even 100% sure about it either. I'm just saying maybe add something like that to give dungeons a kick.
Stronghold
-Has a chest in almost every room(Major loot)
-Lots of Monsters(Thrill and Experience)
-At the end of it, you get to go to a new dimension(and fight a sweet Boss!)
-And a bunch of other stuff I can't think of
Well there you have it. That's how awesome strongholds are. Now to the dungeons. You'll see how not as awesome they are compared to strongholds.
Dungeons
-Have 1 or 2 chests total(Minor loot)
-Monster spawner(Mob farm and experience)
- 1 room. Just 1 whole room.
Now you see? If I had a choice, I'd go looking for a stronghold instead of a dungeon. And the dungeon is in only 1 room. JUST ONE ROOM! I mean, look at the definition of Dungeon
dun·geon
ˈdənjən/
noun
1.
verba strong underground prison cell, especially in a castle.
synonyms:
underground prison, oubliette; More
literary
1.
http://achievecraft.com/generate.php
imprison (someone) in a dungeon.
That's the definition. In nowhere do you see "One small room with minor loot". Here is a picture of a typical minecraft dungeon I made
That's a typical dungeon(minus the pig spawner and torch). Now my Idea is to make MORE than one room into the dungeon. Here I have built a room.
That's a long hall with traps and chests. You can mine through the wall or you can mine the iron bars.
Here is inside of it. You can see 3 dispensers and a chest way in the back if you look.
This is in dispenser 1. Potions of Weakness for 1:01 and you do 0.5 less attack damage. The second one has arrows in it but I didn't get a screen shot.
The third has, you guessed it, fire charges. Then we get the chest and find out it has...
Loot fit for a king! Next I have a mini library. I know the stronghold already has one but this is a mini one.
The library has bookcases, cobwebs, a chest, and a witch. Also there were a couple bats spawning in but that doesn't matter. Finally here is a picture of the finished stronghold outside.
The little stone things on the hall are meant to cover up the dispenser.
Well there you have it. I am finished rambling out Dungeons now and you probably never want to read something ever again but I hope my suggestion gets support and post your dungeon room ideas down in the comments. And would you hit that little green arrow in the lower right hand corner if you give support? Thank you for your time and answer the poll! It's important.
EDIT: You can get the Custom achievement right here!
I didn't mean for Mojang to fully on update dungeons, but it would be nice if they added a new room or something. Maybe a second spawner or something to make dungeons better. They're just a little plain and boring. Not in a "Plain and boring way so let's make a better dungeon mod" but in a way so that just give dungeons a little kick
Ok , keep the small dungeons and add big ones ?
Yes but if Mojang doesn't occasionally update Dungeons they'll be long and forgotten so when new players(or old ones who haven't played in a while) will find a dungeon and be like "Hey I found a new structure they must have added!' then they take a screenshot, post it here on the forums, then finally someone breaks it to them and says "Nope sorry, that's an old structure called a dungeon but Mojang didn't keep updating it so it's rare to find one". Then eventually Mojang could realize they haven't updated it then just remove the dungeon itself completely from the game and I'm one of the people that's doesn't want this to happen. That's why I want Mojang to update Dungeons.
Maybe we add something like obsidian to block the dispensers but that'll just raise suspicion to finding the dungeon. So I'll keep trying and experimenting.
Yes , they also mine the walls of jungle temples to get the arrows and completely jump the puzzle by breaking it to reach the chest . Hah ?
-Added tripwire hooks(like wailwail suggested)
-Changed the chest to a trapped chest(when opened sets off TNT under the dungeon)
Pictures
EDIT: That'll keep people from breaking the walls and missing all of the traps
There are an infinite number of dungeons in every Minecraft world. If they all contained super rare stuff like End Portals, it would be very overpowered. While it would be neat if they were updated to be more than a tiny box, I don't support any HUGE overhaul.
Dungeons aren't infinite , so as the Minecraft world , it is 30.000.000 blocks wide . but that's enough to find billions of dungeons ...
True, and we didn't need too many of it
Dungeons should be what it be, if the dungeon gets upgraded and became more bigger, then miners would be easy to find it. And loot everything that he find (even the walls)
No Support
See All The Collections Of Minecraft Journals!
http://www.minecraft.../#entry30669911
And Remember To Keep Every Journals Alive!
Overall, an interesting concept. Maybe a bit of tweaking on the loot, but besides that I like the idea and the size of it. I'll give a 75% Support on this one.
I need my beautiful little egg to grow up, so please, feed it those tasty clicks! Also, regarding the adults, they'll click you.PROUD USER OF THE STEVE SKIN
True, and we didn't need too many of it
Dungeons should be what it be, if the dungeon gets upgraded and became more bigger, then miners would be easy to find it. And loot everything that he find (even the walls)
No Support
Ok , then Dungeons should be kept the way they are , make them a little bit rarer , and add the big dungeons . with the same chance of spawning as desert temples but underground .
-Added less OP loot(as suggested by many people
Here is an example. I realized that all of the diamonds and stuff was too OP.
Full Support :D.
I need my beautiful little egg to grow up, so please, feed it those tasty clicks! Also, regarding the adults, they'll click you.The sword has looting 3
I'm not saying to majorly update it. Just add a room or 2. The Library might not even happen I wasn't even 100% sure about it either. I'm just saying maybe add something like that to give dungeons a kick.