It got GoTY and it got best RPG of all time. That should be enough. I not, watch this review by IGN, it got a rating of 9.5:
(It's for PC, but there isn't much of a difference.)
GOTY means nothing MW3 got GOTY doesn't mean it deserves it. Too many GOTY are handed out for them to even matter and Skyrim got theirs from Spike... and they are reputable. Skyrim BF3 and MW3 did not deserve GOTY because Skyrim was literally broken with several obvious flaws in its optimization to be the worst BGS games released in stability. MW3 DLC for MW2 pretty much they havn't deserved a GOTY for the last 3 games let but Activisoin has the largest PR market in the industry currently. Battlefield 3 its not Battlefield false advertising there and people judged it on its campaign should not even exist MP with bots = best.
Various games including Deux ex, Uncharted 3, Witcher 2, Batman Arkham City, Bastion, Trine all deserved GOTY more so then the 3 titles in the poll.
I dont understand what all this skyrim hype is about....it's not even online
Actually there is a MP mod for PC while its in production it is looking better then Oblivion's MP mod and actually may be somewhat finished this time. As for a game needing MP to be good that is a joke..
GOTY means nothing MW3 got GOTY doesn't mean it deserves it. Too many GOTY are handed out for them to even matter and Skyrim got theirs from Spike... and they are reputable. Skyrim BF3 and MW3 did not deserve GOTY because Skyrim was literally broken with several obvious flaws in its optimization to be the worst BGS games released in stability. MW3 DLC for MW2 pretty much they havn't deserved a GOTY for the last 3 games let but Activisoin has the largest PR market in the industry currently. Battlefield 3 its not Battlefield false advertising there and people judged it on its campaign should not even exist MP with bots = best.
Various games including Deux ex, Uncharted 3, Witcher 2, Batman Arkham City, Bastion, Trine all deserved GOTY more so then the 3 titles in the poll.
Actually there is a MP mod for PC while its in production it is looking better then Oblivion's MP mod and actually may be somewhat finished this time. As for a game needing MP to be good that is a joke..
Both are losing my interest though
This topic is asking which game is preferred out of these THREE...
*facepalm*