I'd like to compile many fishing content ideas here because they have mentioned that they want to add new fishing content because fishing isn't really cool right now. If you know of other cool fishing ideas post the idea and any link it may need and I'll edit it into the front page of this post.
1. More items being fished out other than Fish. http://www.minecraft...s-when-fishing/ Seems logical to me since I've actually fished before. Ever think you got a big one and you really just snagged an old bottle stuck in the mud? Maybe that will finally be a good thing. Free Leather Boots, Water Bottles, Sticks, and other random goodies.
2. Different mediums to fish in. Lava? Clouds? Portals? Maybe the answer really is "Location, location, location."
3. Fishing Poles being used to grab dropped items. This seems like a logical way to prove your aim (and grab things in hard to reach places).
4. More seafood. Ever get tired of just plain Fish? Lobsters, Oysters (Ender Pearls maybe?), Crabs, Kalimari (those Squids have been thought of before).
5. Custom Fishing Poles. This is for serious fisherman only. Bobbers, bait, better line (more durability without Unbreaking), winch (more pull-back versus mobs).
1. Why would that be a "good thing"? I don't see the point in that.
2. Huh?
3. Sure. It would even open up new gamemodes.
4. Then suggest what extra seafood is.
5. ...Yeah, again, please explain this further. "Serious fisherman only"? What?
Don't give us a bunch of "you know the drill" ideas. Add some detail so we know 100% what you're aiming at, and also so other posters might not take you out of context due to lack of explanation.
1. Much better. This sounds alright.
2. I don't think a fishing rod (or fish) would work well in lava. Or clouds... Portals wouldn't make much sense, because it's not like some Nether-bound fish was just on the other side of your portal when it wasn't.
4. Meh. Fishing in new food sprites that all do the same thing doesn't seem worth the time to add.
5. We already use bobbers by default. The bait is interesting. No point in adding durability when an enchantment covers it.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hey, you there. Yes, you! Are you thinking about posting a suggestion on the forums anytime soon? If so, please read this before doing so.
1. Much better. This sounds alright.
2. I don't think a fishing rod (or fish) would work well in lava. Or clouds... Portals wouldn't make much sense, because it's not like some Nether-bound fish was just on the other side of your portal when it wasn't.
4. Meh. Fishing in new food sprites that all do the same thing doesn't seem worth the time to add.
5. We already use bobbers by default. The bait is interesting. No point in adding durability when an enchantment covers it.
1. Much better. This sounds alright.
2. I don't think a fishing rod (or fish) would work well in lava. Or clouds... Portals wouldn't make much sense, because it's not like some Nether-bound fish was just on the other side of your portal when it wasn't.
4. Meh. Fishing in new food sprites that all do the same thing doesn't seem worth the time to add.
5. We already use bobbers by default. The bait is interesting. No point in adding durability when an enchantment covers it.
5. I meant specialty bobbers, like one that speeds up fishing or one that distracts mobs. Sonic bobber to go with your screwdriver?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If regular is Vanilla then what flavor is your Minecraft?
5. I meant specialty bobbers, like one that speeds up fishing or one that distracts mobs.
I see. That sounds a little overpowered. Like you could make mobs walk into a trap by just casting a bobber there. Something to speed up fishing wouldn't be bad, but would need some serious balance so you don't have a 100% catch rate.
Sonic bobber to go with your screwdriver?
Uhhh..??
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hey, you there. Yes, you! Are you thinking about posting a suggestion on the forums anytime soon? If so, please read this before doing so.
1) In favor,
2) While humorous, I don't agree with "fishing" though Portals, Lava, or Clouds
3) in favor,
4) Meh, not for or against.
5) Bait, yes, if better fish (#4) is implemented, otherwise and to all else, no.
1. More items being fished out other than Fish. http://www.minecraft...s-when-fishing/ Seems logical to me since I've actually fished before. Ever think you got a big one and you really just snagged an old bottle stuck in the mud? Maybe that will finally be a good thing. Free Leather Boots, Water Bottles, Sticks, and other random goodies.
2. Different mediums to fish in. Lava? Clouds? Portals? Maybe the answer really is "Location, location, location."
3. Fishing Poles being used to grab dropped items. This seems like a logical way to prove your aim (and grab things in hard to reach places).
4. More seafood. Ever get tired of just plain Fish? Lobsters, Oysters (Ender Pearls maybe?), Crabs, Kalimari (those Squids have been thought of before).
5. Custom Fishing Poles. This is for serious fisherman only. Bobbers, bait, better line (more durability without Unbreaking), winch (more pull-back versus mobs).
1. I like the boots and the sticks. It would be fun!
2. I suppose there could be some sort of lava-fish in the Nether, but it may not work so well with vanilla.
3. Not a bad idea actually.
4. Let's keep it comfortably simple, some of this may work better in a mod.
5. More of a mod thing, but it would be a good mod.
And as a suggestion how about spear fishing, and physical fish (as hinted by Dinnerbone).
It could add variety as a single tier weapon, and create a more engaging form of fishing.
1. I like the boots and the sticks. It would be fun!
2. I suppose there could be some sort of lava-fish in the Nether, but it may not work so well with vanilla.
3. Not a bad idea actually.
4. Let's keep it comfortably simple, some of this may work better in a mod.
5. More of a mod thing, but it would be a good mod.
And as a suggestion how about spear fishing, and physical fish (as hinted by Dinnerbone).
It could add variety as a single tier weapon, and create a more engaging form of fishing.
Add some String to that recipe for harpoon fishing!
1) In favor,
2) While humorous, I don't agree with "fishing" though Portals, Lava, or Clouds
3) in favor,
4) Meh, not for or against.
5) Bait, yes, if better fish (#4) is implemented, otherwise and to all else, no.
I think this is meant to be a Doctor Who reference.
Yep. Doctor Who!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
If regular is Vanilla then what flavor is your Minecraft?
1. More items being fished out other than Fish. http://www.minecraft...s-when-fishing/ Seems logical to me since I've actually fished before. Ever think you got a big one and you really just snagged an old bottle stuck in the mud? Maybe that will finally be a good thing. Free Leather Boots, Water Bottles, Sticks, and other random goodies.
2. Different mediums to fish in. Lava? Clouds? Portals? Maybe the answer really is "Location, location, location."
3. Fishing Poles being used to grab dropped items. This seems like a logical way to prove your aim (and grab things in hard to reach places).
4. More seafood. Ever get tired of just plain Fish? Lobsters, Oysters (Ender Pearls maybe?), Crabs, Kalimari (those Squids have been thought of before).
5. Custom Fishing Poles. This is for serious fisherman only. Bobbers, bait, better line (more durability without Unbreaking), winch (more pull-back versus mobs).
If regular is Vanilla then what flavor is your Minecraft?
2. Huh?
3. Sure. It would even open up new gamemodes.
4. Then suggest what extra seafood is.
5. ...Yeah, again, please explain this further. "Serious fisherman only"? What?
Don't give us a bunch of "you know the drill" ideas. Add some detail so we know 100% what you're aiming at, and also so other posters might not take you out of context due to lack of explanation.
If regular is Vanilla then what flavor is your Minecraft?
1. Much better. This sounds alright.
2. I don't think a fishing rod (or fish) would work well in lava. Or clouds... Portals wouldn't make much sense, because it's not like some Nether-bound fish was just on the other side of your portal when it wasn't.
4. Meh. Fishing in new food sprites that all do the same thing doesn't seem worth the time to add.
5. We already use bobbers by default. The bait is interesting. No point in adding durability when an enchantment covers it.
5. I meant specialty bobbers, like one that speeds up fishing or one that distracts mobs. Sonic bobber to go with your screwdriver?
If regular is Vanilla then what flavor is your Minecraft?
I see. That sounds a little overpowered. Like you could make mobs walk into a trap by just casting a bobber there. Something to speed up fishing wouldn't be bad, but would need some serious balance so you don't have a 100% catch rate.
Uhhh..??
2) While humorous, I don't agree with "fishing" though Portals, Lava, or Clouds
3) in favor,
4) Meh, not for or against.
5) Bait, yes, if better fish (#4) is implemented, otherwise and to all else, no.
I think this is meant to be a Doctor Who reference.
1. I like the boots and the sticks. It would be fun!
2. I suppose there could be some sort of lava-fish in the Nether, but it may not work so well with vanilla.
3. Not a bad idea actually.
4. Let's keep it comfortably simple, some of this may work better in a mod.
5. More of a mod thing, but it would be a good mod.
And as a suggestion how about spear fishing, and physical fish (as hinted by Dinnerbone).
It could add variety as a single tier weapon, and create a more engaging form of fishing.
http://www.minecraft...orld-version-3/
Add some String to that recipe for harpoon fishing!
Yep. Doctor Who!
If regular is Vanilla then what flavor is your Minecraft?
If regular is Vanilla then what flavor is your Minecraft?