This idea is definitely a good one - it's cool and clever - but I just don't think it has a place yet. There's still barely anything to do in Minecraft's oceans yet, or any good reason to traverse them. Sure, if this were added, lots of people would just build and sail boats around, but I think many more still wouldn't and this feature wouldn't live up to its potential. Before this is implemented, the oceans would really need to be expanded on and filled out, both with life and general things. While I like the idea, for now I have to say I can only give it Partial Support, since it's not overly beneficial yet.
This idea is definitely a good one - it's cool and clever - but I just don't think it has a place yet. There's still barely anything to do in Minecraft's oceans yet, or any good reason to traverse them. Sure, if this were added, lots of people would just build and sail boats around, but I think many more still wouldn't and this feature wouldn't live up to its potential. Before this is implemented, the oceans would really need to be expanded on and filled out, both with life and general things. While I like the idea, for now I have to say I can only give it Partial Support, since it's not overly beneficial yet.
If they were to make this they'd probably add ocean mobs. Also alot of people would use boats for a second house, a house, a base, or decoration.
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
5/26/2015
Posts:
56
Member Details
I just wached the minecraft movie trailer and there should be more intelegent villagers and the monsters are smarter and villagers can go to the end and nether.
Wow I really like this, especially the Cog and Carrack... Who hasn't wanted to live a nomadic life style on the sea at some point? Land travel nomadic living doesn't really work well due to any kind travel wagons getting caught on everything.
The ocean is the only terrain that is flat and would allow for large scale adventure, although oceans should be more interconnected. (not bigger but more connected instead of the silly sand bars and such that disconnect them)
Edit because I forgot to write this: The galleon is a bit much but it might have its place, as long as it's very late game and could be used as a base
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
i said something about a transport boat with 4 cannnons and 15-24 chests
No, that's far to few cannons, if it has so much space you'll need plenty of protection for when an escort isn't available or has been destroyed.
A transport is a high profile target, providing you have the correct cargo...
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
I would think that 4 cannons would do well for a research vessel, research the ocean in style!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
I like the idea of a research vessel but what would you research ?
And what mobs would be in this?
I don't know... perhaps the sea floor and scout areas for mines or bases? And research the sea floor, none of the boats or ships so far have really been aimed at base scouting/sea floor scouting.
It should be fast so it can double as a spy ship one a factions/role play server... Spy on your enemies with the Spy-O-Boat 3000!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
anyone there
hello
is anyone even here or i the disscusion over
This idea is definitely a good one - it's cool and clever - but I just don't think it has a place yet. There's still barely anything to do in Minecraft's oceans yet, or any good reason to traverse them. Sure, if this were added, lots of people would just build and sail boats around, but I think many more still wouldn't and this feature wouldn't live up to its potential. Before this is implemented, the oceans would really need to be expanded on and filled out, both with life and general things. While I like the idea, for now I have to say I can only give it Partial Support, since it's not overly beneficial yet.
I support, but you should also TEAM UP with the mythological sea creatures dude to make a SUPER SUGGESTION
My signature is broken. I am currently fixing it
You can support my suggestions at:
Kiwi birds: -The link broke-
Every biome gets at least 1 mob: -The link broke-
Pirates: -The link broke-
Chorus apes: -The link broke
If they were to make this they'd probably add ocean mobs. Also alot of people would use boats for a second house, a house, a base, or decoration.
I just wached the minecraft movie trailer and there should be more intelegent villagers and the monsters are smarter and villagers can go to the end and nether.
Looks awesome
Wow I really like this, especially the Cog and Carrack... Who hasn't wanted to live a nomadic life style on the sea at some point? Land travel nomadic living doesn't really work well due to any kind travel wagons getting caught on everything.
The ocean is the only terrain that is flat and would allow for large scale adventure, although oceans should be more interconnected. (not bigger but more connected instead of the silly sand bars and such that disconnect them)
Edit because I forgot to write this: The galleon is a bit much but it might have its place, as long as it's very late game and could be used as a base
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oden so what I'm soup? Fish soup?
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
OHHH U FELL FOR IT! OOOOOHHH
well the galleon would be able to be bilt in the early game if you just got a bunch of wood and wool
Dude. Your post was archived. Repost in the minecraft suggestionbox subreddit
My signature is broken. I am currently fixing it
You can support my suggestions at:
Kiwi birds: -The link broke-
Every biome gets at least 1 mob: -The link broke-
Pirates: -The link broke-
Chorus apes: -The link broke
i said something about a transport boat with 4 cannnons and 15-24 chests
No, that's far to few cannons, if it has so much space you'll need plenty of protection for when an escort isn't available or has been destroyed.
A transport is a high profile target, providing you have the correct cargo...
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oden so what I'm soup? Fish soup?
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
OHHH U FELL FOR IT! OOOOOHHH
makes sence 8 or 10 cannons would work better
I would think that 4 cannons would do well for a research vessel, research the ocean in style!
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oden so what I'm soup? Fish soup?
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
OHHH U FELL FOR IT! OOOOOHHH
http://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions
Timeless Modding is kinda dead but idk what to put here now
I occasionally make textures/models for random people. Contributed to: Tinker's Construct, Growthcraft, and Animals+
PixelQuest 2, my new 1.10 RPG/rougelike-inspired modpack, is coming soon!
The link just took me to the subreddit. I can't find your post...
My signature is broken. I am currently fixing it
You can support my suggestions at:
Kiwi birds: -The link broke-
Every biome gets at least 1 mob: -The link broke-
Pirates: -The link broke-
Chorus apes: -The link broke
I love the idea of bigger boats.
I like the idea of a research vessel but what would you research ?
And what mobs would be in this?
I don't know... perhaps the sea floor and scout areas for mines or bases? And research the sea floor, none of the boats or ships so far have really been aimed at base scouting/sea floor scouting.
It should be fast so it can double as a spy ship one a factions/role play server... Spy on your enemies with the Spy-O-Boat 3000!
I made a Feed The Beast modpack! Simply type "Experiment812390" without quotes into the 3rD party codes area and you can see the mods list and install!
Don't be a pedant, or take things out of context on purpose.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oden so what I'm soup? Fish soup?
"don't quote yourself in your signature it makes you look silly" ~ Oden_The_Fish
#Baum4God
my profile picture is the A-10 thunderbolt II the successor of the first thunderbolt used in WWII by the USAF both excel in air support and ground attacks
the A-10 also sports the GAU-8 Avenger a 30MM hydraulic gatling type autocannon
OHHH U FELL FOR IT! OOOOOHHH