Maybe Mojang and Microsoft could add a new ore, only mined with a diamond pick, the green Malachite ore! Some of you may know this from skyrim by the way!
Malachite could be made into tools that mine a bit faster than diamond tools. They cannot mine obsidian, but they can mine all the ores including its own ore! It could be also made into buckets, which could hold 3 times more storage!
So guys, what do you say. Do you go on and support my idea, ang give it the love it deserves? Or, do you hate my idea, but like it a tad of some things, and not support it?
Ugh, more people complaining about new ores. I WANT A NEW ORE, IS THAT A PROBLEM?
I'm not complaining, I'm criticising your suggestion. That's the entire point of this forum, to get constructive critiscism on suggestions. If you make a suggestion, be prepared to take criticism.
I'm not complaining, I'm criticising your suggestion. That's the entire point of this forum, to get constructive critiscism on suggestions. If you make a suggestion, be prepared to take criticism.
Umm tbch, that wasn't EXACTly constructive, but sorry...
Umm tbch, that wasn't EXACTly constructive, but sorry...
"Constructive" does not always mean "positive." If someone is giving you constructive criticism on something, they will not always go and say "woah dude this is the best suggestion ever theres nothing wrong with it its awesome!!!" In this case, he was saying "Why do we need a new ore?" It's a legitimate question. Minecraft already has plenty of ores. Suggesting a new ore for the sake of a new ore doesn't really do much. (By the way, Mojang has said there will never be an ore above diamond.) Speaking of it being above diamond, how is malachite stronger than diamond? In real life, malachite is copper. Copper is in no way better than diamond. Now, with all of that said, it doesn't mean that there's no reason at all for a new ore. If you were suggesting some other mechanic that this new ore was a part of, then that could be more considerable, but as is there is no need for another ore. Even the "bucket that holds 3 times more" thing doesn't really make sense. How does a bucket made of the exact same amount of material as a normal bucket have more storage? Is it some sort of TARDIS bucket? And why do we need that anyways? With all that said, keep in mind that I'm not saying you're a horrible person, I'm not absolutely trashing your suggestion, I'm telling you how it could be improved. That's what constructive criticism is. Now it's your choice how you respond.
A new ore that just makes tools better than diamond tools is overpowered. Also making 3 buckets is easy enough, a Malachite bucket seems like a waste of the ore.
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Location:
Behind you.
Join Date:
5/25/2015
Posts:
46
Location:
Behind you.
Minecraft:
TheRedstoneRazor
Xbox:
PC Master Race.
PSN:
PC Master Race.
Member Details
Pros:
If done right, it could help add more variety to the game
The fact that it mines faster than diamond yet isn't quite as powerful is certainly a good way to balance things out and make the tool tier more unique
Cons:
Adding an extra tier of tool with no special features could just be repetitive and simply make the game more grindy
Taking things from other games is generally very strongly frowned upon.
You haven't fully described the mineral yet - attack speed and damage, enchantment-luck and rarity are just some I can come up with from the top of my head. Needs more work!
Other Points:
The bucket idea does seem pretty random, but bucket tiers and adding durability to buckets could even be worth its own thread
Malachite is actually a type of copper, which has been agreed by the community to be most likely to go between stone and iron
If done right, it could help add more variety to the game
The fact that it mines faster than diamond yet isn't quite as powerful is certainly a good way to balance things out and make the tool tier more unique
Cons:
Adding an extra tier of tool with no special features could just be repetitive and simply make the game more grindy
Taking things from other games is generally very strongly frowned upon.
You haven't fully described the mineral yet - attack speed and damage, enchantment-luck and rarity are just some I can come up with from the top of my head. Needs more work!
Other Points:
The bucket idea does seem pretty random, but bucket tiers and adding durability to buckets could even be worth its own thread
Malachite is actually a type of copper, which has been agreed by the community to be most likely to go between stone and iron
Umm.. its not a new tier at all... its just got better efficiency, like gold...
Gold is a tier. Things having better efficiency than other things makes them tires. Any new ore malleable enough to be forged into the current kinds of tools would be considered a new tier. What you're suggesting is a new tier of tools.
Gold is a tier. Things having better efficiency than other things makes them tires. Any new ore malleable enough to be forged into the current kinds of tools would be considered a new tier. What you're suggesting is a new tier of tools.
Maybe Mojang and Microsoft could add a new ore, only mined with a diamond pick, the green Malachite ore! Some of you may know this from skyrim by the way!
Malachite could be made into tools that mine a bit faster than diamond tools. They cannot mine obsidian, but they can mine all the ores including its own ore! It could be also made into buckets, which could hold 3 times more storage!
So guys, what do you say. Do you go on and support my idea, ang give it the love it deserves? Or, do you hate my idea, but like it a tad of some things, and not support it?
It's your decision!
Why do we need a new ore? You seem to want a new ore just for the sake of it.
Please don't PM me asking for help, I will just redirect you to the appropriate forum, where there are others who are far more skilled than me.
This is not the signature you are looking for.
Banners and such things
Ugh, more people complaining about new ores. I WANT A NEW ORE, IS THAT A PROBLEM?
I'm not complaining, I'm criticising your suggestion. That's the entire point of this forum, to get constructive critiscism on suggestions. If you make a suggestion, be prepared to take criticism.
Please don't PM me asking for help, I will just redirect you to the appropriate forum, where there are others who are far more skilled than me.
This is not the signature you are looking for.
Banners and such things
Umm tbch, that wasn't EXACTly constructive, but sorry...
Malachite isn't from skyrim... It's a real life copper ore. Copper is a metal.
Checkout my mod about Craftable End Portal frames!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/mapping-and-modding/minecraft-mods/2656035-craftable-end-portal-frames
Check out my YT Channel https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCaJyJFtI-BkO1a2OJTZbofw Please subscribe and like my vidz!
"Constructive" does not always mean "positive." If someone is giving you constructive criticism on something, they will not always go and say "woah dude this is the best suggestion ever theres nothing wrong with it its awesome!!!" In this case, he was saying "Why do we need a new ore?" It's a legitimate question. Minecraft already has plenty of ores. Suggesting a new ore for the sake of a new ore doesn't really do much. (By the way, Mojang has said there will never be an ore above diamond.) Speaking of it being above diamond, how is malachite stronger than diamond? In real life, malachite is copper. Copper is in no way better than diamond. Now, with all of that said, it doesn't mean that there's no reason at all for a new ore. If you were suggesting some other mechanic that this new ore was a part of, then that could be more considerable, but as is there is no need for another ore. Even the "bucket that holds 3 times more" thing doesn't really make sense. How does a bucket made of the exact same amount of material as a normal bucket have more storage? Is it some sort of TARDIS bucket? And why do we need that anyways? With all that said, keep in mind that I'm not saying you're a horrible person, I'm not absolutely trashing your suggestion, I'm telling you how it could be improved. That's what constructive criticism is. Now it's your choice how you respond.
asdf
Would there be Malachite armor? If so, will it be better than diamond armor?
We seriously need new ores in my opinion.
YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC21Z2rupws5IulGQMxB1Plg
Yeah, there would, but it would be 9 armour points when fully equipped.
A new ore that just makes tools better than diamond tools is overpowered. Also making 3 buckets is easy enough, a Malachite bucket seems like a waste of the ore.
No Supprot
hi
Okay then, I get it, it's a bad suggestion...
If they do add this then they would probably need to add more Armor Points (rather than 10, is it?).
YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC21Z2rupws5IulGQMxB1Plg
Don't steal stuff from other games.
A tire higher than diamond should mine obsidian.
We don't need another tire of tools.
The only thing interesting about this suggestion is the bucket, which alone doesn't warrant the ore.
BA
Pros:
Cons:
Other Points:
Moderate Support.
8 PLAYER SKYBLOCK - CLASSIC SKYBLOCK MADE COMPETETIVE!
Is survival too easy for you? Try this: http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/redstone-discussion-and/command-blocks/2433897-harder-survival-vmod-v1-1-is-out
Hmm... maybe I'll edit this thread then
Umm.. its not a new tier at all... its just got better efficiency, like gold...
Gold is a tier. Things having better efficiency than other things makes them tires. Any new ore malleable enough to be forged into the current kinds of tools would be considered a new tier. What you're suggesting is a new tier of tools.
BA
lolno its not
It is...? Armor is separated into 5 different tiers: leather, chain, iron, gold and diamond.
What is your idea of a tier then?
by tier i mean HARVEST LEVEL...