Hmm.. I never had Problems with ender eyes. Sorry that i cant help you :/
That really doesn't help him much...
OP, chances are you world does not have an Ender Portal for some reason which is not giving the throwing animation to you since it can not locate the portal. I don't think it matters if the area was discovered on your map or not but maybe you should test it on another world and see what happens.
I got my enderman pearls on normal, and my blaze rods on easy.
My eye of ender will not work/activate using L2 or R2. But. A friend just crafted one in his world and it worked fine.
I've been walking around my entire world while pressing L2, trying to see if nearing the portal might trigger it.
Can someone tell me what I'm doing wrong?
That really doesn't help him much...
OP, chances are you world does not have an Ender Portal for some reason which is not giving the throwing animation to you since it can not locate the portal. I don't think it matters if the area was discovered on your map or not but maybe you should test it on another world and see what happens.