I feel people are just being nice voting for Nemo. It's a super generic simple pack with lots of ctm textures (why you made that many I don't even know).
In that regard, the criteria of quality, I completely agree with you Lilyo. Fish's pack is behind a good 4-5 other choices.
BUT in terms of overall completion (in addition to challenge's requirements), he exceeds any other pack, in terms of effort, he probably put forth more hours of work than any other artist in the competition, not to mention that his pack's palette isn't too shabby, nor are his textures that "un-detailed."
It's a nifty pack. Fish did a solid job. You don't have to degrade his work. Lilyo, I've learned how you are as a forum member, and understand that you're quite a critical person, but it's not that bad that deserves a strictly negative comment. I'm not looking to bring down your opinion, nobody has the right to do that, but it doesn't deserve the criticality of your comment. Just an opinion on your opinion. He certainly knocked down some other criteria that one should consider!
Anyways, Good Work to all competitors! Congrats to those in the lead!
P.S: Not looking to start something here. Looking positively is just the way to go in my own mentality. I think the forums needs someone who iss always going to back up his own opinion, but come on, Nemo is not a pack that's poor enough to degrade, without a positive outlook on its successes.
Not to be an ass, but the scope of the competition only covers the terrain.png, not the rest of the pack. People should only be judging based on that, because it's not fair to the people who only completed the terrain.
Understood. Don't think I poured my heart out there or anything! Lilyo's a loyal member and I certainly respect his and everyone elses opinion. I'm not even saying that I voted for Nemo's pack, nor will I likely use it, but it doesn't deserve degration without mentioning the effort, at least, that wen into its creation.
It was a tough choice between Home Sweet Home or Nemo. The sheer effort that went into Nemo and all of its GUI and items was pretty intense, but I ended up choosing Home Sweet Home, because I love the style of it and I feel like I would rather play with Home Sweet Home over Nemo on a day-to-day basis.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Learn some Java before you mod, and skip over the chapter on ModLoader, straight to MinecraftForge. It's better. Trust me.
I feel people are just being nice voting for Nemo. It's a super generic simple pack with lots of ctm textures (why you made that many I don't even know).
Lilyo, I have an incredible ammount of respect for you, but I think that comment was a bit too rude.
Fish has put a lot of time and effort into that pack, and I do not think it is unoriginal at all. The designs have a consistent, unique theme, and the mass addition of CTM makes it even more unique.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The official Bluebird continuation is underway! Please come and help keep the pack alive!
Considering there is no real "reward", it's not anything to fret over.
But it does stand to question, if only the terrain is being voted on then why are many other images included with various packs. I have nearly a whole second terrain that also is not part of the challenge but was created for the same pack. Should that be added to my submission and also considered by voters? Personally I think not.
Considering there is no real "reward", it's not anything to fret over.
But it does stand to question, if only the terrain is being voted on then why are many other images included with various packs. I have nearly a whole second terrain that also is not part of the challenge but was created for the same pack. Should that be added to my submission and also considered by voters? Personally I think not.
I put in everything people submitted for their entries, but on second thought you're right, I need to go take out all the extra stuff.
EDIT: Done. Took out both mine and fish's extra stuff.
EDIT: So what DO you guys want? Tekkit blocks? Vanilla items? Vanilla mobs? More CTM?
Plenty of Fish, I voted for your pack because I feel it really represents what a simple pack should be without being too detailed or so boring no one cares*. =)
You should finish the items.
*NOTE: I do not think anyone made a 'no one cares' pack in this competition. I was referring to the ever famous 'paint bucket fill' packs.
EDIT: I should also note that had I not loved Fish's pack, I would have voted forDahlia or Chocolate Sparkles!
voted for Lord_Retardus, i liked his style and i plan to use it in a series i'm makin. I hope to get his individual support and help in specialising it! Good job all!
Once again,
DUN DUN DUUUUUNNNN....
I'll update Nemo tomorrow with like CTM and more stuff.
Thankyou so much guys!
I'll work super hard on the pack tommorow, before AND after school stuff.
(That's Fish talk for the Audi Ventus fans changed their mind, which is sad because now Deonyi will be sad)
http://www.livestream.com/fishsofficiallivestream
Come have fun!
BUT in terms of overall completion (in addition to challenge's requirements), he exceeds any other pack, in terms of effort, he probably put forth more hours of work than any other artist in the competition, not to mention that his pack's palette isn't too shabby, nor are his textures that "un-detailed."
It's a nifty pack. Fish did a solid job. You don't have to degrade his work. Lilyo, I've learned how you are as a forum member, and understand that you're quite a critical person, but it's not that bad that deserves a strictly negative comment. I'm not looking to bring down your opinion, nobody has the right to do that, but it doesn't deserve the criticality of your comment. Just an opinion on your opinion. He certainly knocked down some other criteria that one should consider!
Anyways, Good Work to all competitors! Congrats to those in the lead!
P.S: Not looking to start something here. Looking positively is just the way to go in my own mentality. I think the forums needs someone who iss always going to back up his own opinion, but come on, Nemo is not a pack that's poor enough to degrade, without a positive outlook on its successes.
Lilyo, I have an incredible ammount of respect for you, but I think that comment was a bit too rude.
Fish has put a lot of time and effort into that pack, and I do not think it is unoriginal at all. The designs have a consistent, unique theme, and the mass addition of CTM makes it even more unique.
But it does stand to question, if only the terrain is being voted on then why are many other images included with various packs. I have nearly a whole second terrain that also is not part of the challenge but was created for the same pack. Should that be added to my submission and also considered by voters? Personally I think not.
Twitter: @Levaunt
I put in everything people submitted for their entries, but on second thought you're right, I need to go take out all the extra stuff.
EDIT: Done. Took out both mine and fish's extra stuff.
Plenty of Fish, I voted for your pack because I feel it really represents what a simple pack should be without being too detailed or so boring no one cares*. =)
You should finish the items.
*NOTE: I do not think anyone made a 'no one cares' pack in this competition. I was referring to the ever famous 'paint bucket fill' packs.
EDIT: I should also note that had I not loved Fish's pack, I would have voted for Dahlia or Chocolate Sparkles!
Wth? I already have 62 downloads for Home Sweet Home....lol.
How about you stop voting like it's a popularity contest and start voting with thought and consideration