Ok, just finished, took me two and a half hour. Really good map and it's obvious from the start how many efforts went into it, but to be honest, first one did some things much better. For example gear progression - in the sequel there was no real challenge in obtaining diamond armor and sword, and towards the ending was really, reaaaally easy, I felt immortal ;]
I might gear down the stuff in the middle but the last armor set you get is supposed to make you immortal
CAN YOU ALSO GIVE A LINK TO UR FIRST MAP IT WAS AWSOME plus i bet many pepole would want to do that map first
and 3 times more content holy god first one was very long but 3 times more content wow super ultra omega long of awsome long that's AWSOME
and i also got all the aceves from first map and that includes die more then 5 times and beat map without dieing(i died 5 times after i finished the map on purpose) and i did that one with apartner i was the only 1 who found iny of the dimond stuff
now i hope to do this one with my best friend i can tell this 1 will have 3 times the awsome due to it's 3 times the content
Well... I finished... and I was far from impressed. This felt like a step-down from KotS with your story and with your builds. I felt like this was far too spawling, and large open areas were just dull, and the puzzles were rather poor. The builds and the texture pack was definently gorgeous though, and just looking through the areas I encounter was definently enjoyable. Unfortunately the voice acting process was really poor, as I know Noxite, who explained the process taken to record voices, and it really could have been done a lot more smoothly. The lack of music from the videos, or other discerning sounds was also really sad. I posted a long review over on the final video for the map, and once I can view them on there, I'll copy it over here.
7.6/10.
EDIT: Well, forget that then. BlameTheController, if you can't accept a long review of any type from someone that isn't entirely positive, then I suggest you get off the internet. Removing my thoughts and comments on your map is just disgusting, and makes you seem like a fair bit of an ass. I'm sorry that I'm not giving a perfect review, but if you can't accept feedback on what you could do to make this better, than you shouldn't be posting at all. Really unprofessional, and completely uncalled for move.
EDIT2: AND YOU'VE BLOCKED ME? You really must be joking. Are you really that scared of negative comments? You really must be joking, mate. That's a bit overkill, hmm?
You spammed an entire video which is not the appropriate place to make a full review.
I do not pretend to think that everyone will enjoy my map, you didn't but nearly everyone else is giving extremely positive feedback. This combined with the fact that your comments were based on incredibly weak arguments means that maybe its not the map. Maybe its you.
More over the manner in which you made the comments was incredibly disrespectful. Before calling anyone else an ass you need to seriously look at your own behavior.
and lastly I did not block you because you didnt like my map, i blocked you because you were spamming.
You spammed an entire video which is not the appropriate place to make a full review.
I do not pretend to think that everyone will enjoy my map, you didn't but nearly everyone else is giving extremely positive feedback. This combined with the fact that your comments were based on incredibly weak arguments means that maybe its not the map. Maybe its you.
More over the manner in which you made the comments was incredibly disrespectful. Before calling anyone else an ass you need to seriously look at your own behavior.
and lastly I did not block you because you didnt like my map, i blocked you because you were spamming.
Please, explain to me how 5 posts, each maxing, with fully fleshed out and realized statements, offering constructive critisism is "spamming". If I used videos to create my narrative, I would have no problem recieving feedback of that nature. I had the video open right then, as I finished the map. I posted my comments where applicable. AS YOU ASKED IN THE VIDEO, may I point out, and you then claim I'm spamming.
I'm seeing nothing but a childish reaction to more negative feedback. And I'm trying to work out how 12 people is "nearly everyone". That's how many views are currently on your final video. That's not a very large group, BlameTheController. You had many faults within the map, especially in your puzzle design and your videos (you need a better way of creating your videos. Giving readers out of context bits of information, without ever giving them the whole script, and then piecing it together sounds *dreadful* and half dead.). Not being able to accept that posted in the place where you asked for feedback is very unprofession, and leads me to thinking you can't accept non-positive feedback. Note the message you sent me: "NEGATIVE comments". I wasn't being negative, and you know that full well. But I'm sorry that you did a good job with your first map, but on the second you made some missteps. A map isn't always going to be great, no matter how much effort goes into it, and being unable to accept critisism is such a horrible misstep, I'm a bit reluctant to bother continuing to support your maps.
Since nobody can see my comments now, and since I can vouch for the fact they were not in any way rude, I cannot figure out where you're coming from. I offered suggestions as to how to improve the map, improve the voice recordings, and commended you for your builds and nice techture pack. However, I had complaints in parts of it, and made them. If you can't accept that, then fine, but don't act as if I did something wrong by providing critisism.
Another thing to mention is the fact that you still have yet to adress any of the comments I made. You simply claim they're all me. So then reply to them, instead of childishly deleting them and blocking me. Finally, I never went beyond perfectly civil, until I was provoked by you. I didn't say a single insulting thing, until I return to Youtube to find my comments deleted, myself blocks, and you sending me the above PM, claiming I'm negatively spamming your video.
You were rude, disrespectful and insulting to not only me but others who worked on the project. To be perfectly blunt I could not care less what you think about me or my map.
You were rude, disrespectful and insulting to not only me but others who worked on the project. To be perfectly blunt I could not care less what you think about me or my map.
Well, I'm sorry again, that you cannot accept constructive critisism on how to make a decent map better. If you didn't want feedback, then you shouldn't have asked for it. It's that simple.
Well, I'm sorry again, that you cannot accept constructive critisism on how to make a decent map better. If you didn't want feedback, then you shouldn't have asked for it. It's that simple.
You did not offer constructive critisism
I have gotten quite a few messages via twitter, youtube, email, and here from people who said they loved the map. If you didnt thats fine but you need to keep the disrepect in check.
I have gotten quite a few messages via twitter, youtube, email, and here from people who said they loved the map. If you didnt thats fine but you need to keep the disrepect in check.
You block me, after removing my large responce, which kept a perfectly acceptable tone, and you're claiming I am the one who needs to "keep my disrespect in check"? I'm sorry, but that comment on its own has been one of the most rude and dispectful things I've seen in a long time from anyone.
Not everyone has to be respectful. I'm a reviewer. I have a mildly snarky tone of voice when I write a review. I'm not going to pull a punch because I'm afraid I'll hurt your feelings. I'm going to give you my opinion, straight up, and not gloss over it with kind words, when none are applicable.
Again, sorry you can't deal with constructive critisism. Maybe it's you, not me.
You did not give constructive critisim you were rude and disrespectful.
I am no going keep going round and round with you. as it is pointless.
And news to you but you will be respectful or you will be ignored. You also need to seriously get your ego in check.
I could very happily say the same to you. Feedback is feedback, and if your ego is so large that you *can't* take even slightly negative feedback, then we have a problem.
I could very happily say the same to you. Feedback is feedback, and if your ego is so large that you *can't* take even slightly negative feedback, then we have a problem.
No, you have a problem. If you continue to act this way then you will not be taken seriously. You are also not being honest about your behavior. I am sorry but this conversation is over.
My Twitter: BlameTC
I might gear down the stuff in the middle but the last armor set you get is supposed to make you immortal
My Twitter: BlameTC
and 3 times more content holy god first one was very long but 3 times more content wow super ultra omega long of awsome long that's AWSOME
and i also got all the aceves from first map and that includes die more then 5 times and beat map without dieing(i died 5 times after i finished the map on purpose) and i did that one with apartner i was the only 1 who found iny of the dimond stuff
now i hope to do this one with my best friend i can tell this 1 will have 3 times the awsome due to it's 3 times the content
plz don't discriminate about my spelling i know it sucks but i try my best
EDIT: Still working on completing the map. I am stuck at the part where you choose two paths. Does anyone know what to do there?
7.6/10.
EDIT: Well, forget that then. BlameTheController, if you can't accept a long review of any type from someone that isn't entirely positive, then I suggest you get off the internet. Removing my thoughts and comments on your map is just disgusting, and makes you seem like a fair bit of an ass. I'm sorry that I'm not giving a perfect review, but if you can't accept feedback on what you could do to make this better, than you shouldn't be posting at all. Really unprofessional, and completely uncalled for move.
EDIT2: AND YOU'VE BLOCKED ME? You really must be joking. Are you really that scared of negative comments? You really must be joking, mate. That's a bit overkill, hmm?
You spammed an entire video which is not the appropriate place to make a full review.
I do not pretend to think that everyone will enjoy my map, you didn't but nearly everyone else is giving extremely positive feedback. This combined with the fact that your comments were based on incredibly weak arguments means that maybe its not the map. Maybe its you.
More over the manner in which you made the comments was incredibly disrespectful. Before calling anyone else an ass you need to seriously look at your own behavior.
and lastly I did not block you because you didnt like my map, i blocked you because you were spamming.
My Twitter: BlameTC
Please, explain to me how 5 posts, each maxing, with fully fleshed out and realized statements, offering constructive critisism is "spamming". If I used videos to create my narrative, I would have no problem recieving feedback of that nature. I had the video open right then, as I finished the map. I posted my comments where applicable. AS YOU ASKED IN THE VIDEO, may I point out, and you then claim I'm spamming.
I'm seeing nothing but a childish reaction to more negative feedback. And I'm trying to work out how 12 people is "nearly everyone". That's how many views are currently on your final video. That's not a very large group, BlameTheController. You had many faults within the map, especially in your puzzle design and your videos (you need a better way of creating your videos. Giving readers out of context bits of information, without ever giving them the whole script, and then piecing it together sounds *dreadful* and half dead.). Not being able to accept that posted in the place where you asked for feedback is very unprofession, and leads me to thinking you can't accept non-positive feedback. Note the message you sent me: "NEGATIVE comments". I wasn't being negative, and you know that full well. But I'm sorry that you did a good job with your first map, but on the second you made some missteps. A map isn't always going to be great, no matter how much effort goes into it, and being unable to accept critisism is such a horrible misstep, I'm a bit reluctant to bother continuing to support your maps.
Since nobody can see my comments now, and since I can vouch for the fact they were not in any way rude, I cannot figure out where you're coming from. I offered suggestions as to how to improve the map, improve the voice recordings, and commended you for your builds and nice techture pack. However, I had complaints in parts of it, and made them. If you can't accept that, then fine, but don't act as if I did something wrong by providing critisism.
Another thing to mention is the fact that you still have yet to adress any of the comments I made. You simply claim they're all me. So then reply to them, instead of childishly deleting them and blocking me. Finally, I never went beyond perfectly civil, until I was provoked by you. I didn't say a single insulting thing, until I return to Youtube to find my comments deleted, myself blocks, and you sending me the above PM, claiming I'm negatively spamming your video.
You were rude, disrespectful and insulting to not only me but others who worked on the project. To be perfectly blunt I could not care less what you think about me or my map.
My Twitter: BlameTC
Well, I'm sorry again, that you cannot accept constructive critisism on how to make a decent map better. If you didn't want feedback, then you shouldn't have asked for it. It's that simple.
btw, mcpatcher is updated now so umm yeah, you might want to fix the original post
You did not offer constructive critisism
I have gotten quite a few messages via twitter, youtube, email, and here from people who said they loved the map. If you didnt thats fine but you need to keep the disrepect in check.
My Twitter: BlameTC
You block me, after removing my large responce, which kept a perfectly acceptable tone, and you're claiming I am the one who needs to "keep my disrespect in check"? I'm sorry, but that comment on its own has been one of the most rude and dispectful things I've seen in a long time from anyone.
Not everyone has to be respectful. I'm a reviewer. I have a mildly snarky tone of voice when I write a review. I'm not going to pull a punch because I'm afraid I'll hurt your feelings. I'm going to give you my opinion, straight up, and not gloss over it with kind words, when none are applicable.
Again, sorry you can't deal with constructive critisism. Maybe it's you, not me.
You did not give constructive critisim you were rude and disrespectful.
I am no going keep going round and round with you. as it is pointless.
And news to you but you will be respectful or you will be ignored. You also need to seriously get your ego in check.
My Twitter: BlameTC
I could very happily say the same to you. Feedback is feedback, and if your ego is so large that you *can't* take even slightly negative feedback, then we have a problem.
No, you have a problem. If you continue to act this way then you will not be taken seriously. You are also not being honest about your behavior. I am sorry but this conversation is over.
My Twitter: BlameTC