There have been many topic asking peoples opinions on which they choose but, they don't test it. In this forum, I will be giving a fair test between Nocheatplus and Anticheat. In this test I will use Nodus 1.7.2 against Nocheatplus 3.10.12-RC-sMD5NET-b700 against Anticheat 2.0.2. I will be using a point system for the following aspects: Features, Blocking Hacks, False Positives, User Opinion. I will first test how Nocheatplus blocks hacks.
Blocking Hacks
Nocheatplus:
Freecam: Partial 2/6 (Was able to go freecam but was not able to interact with blocks of a radius of 5)
Fly: Blocked 6/6
Highjump: Blocked 6/6
Nofall: Blocked 6/6
Sneak: Blocked 6/6
Spider: Blocked 6/6
Sprint: Allowed 0/6
Step: Blocked 6/6
Water Walking: Blocked 6/6
AutoSign: Blocked 6/6
AutoTool: Allowed: 0/6
AutoMine: Allowed 0/6
FastBreak: Blocked 6/6
FastPlace: Allowed 0/6
Nuker: Blocked 6/6
BowAimbot: Allowed 0/6
ClickAimbot: Blocked 6/6
ForeField: Blocked 6/6
AutoEgg: Blocked 6/6
AutoFish: Allowed 0/6
NoSwing: Blocked 6/6
NoSlownDown: Partial 3/6 Score: 89/132
AntiCheat:
Fly: Blocked 6/6
Freecam: Allowed 0/6
HighJump: Blocked 6/6
NoFall: Partial 1/6 (While jumping it thought I was flying and when I fell it only took away 1 heart)
Sneak: Allowed 0/6
Spider: Blocked 6/6
Sprint: Allowed 0/6
Step: Blocked 5/6 (First time I tried it allowed it)
Water Walking: Allowed 0/6
AutoSign: Allowed 0/6
AutoTool: Allowed 0/6
AutoMine: Allowed 0/6
FastBreak: Partial 4/6 (After multiple tries, I was able to break the blocks)
FastPlace: Blocked 6/6
Nuker: Partial 3/6
BowAimbot: Allowed 0/6
ClickAimbot: Allowed 0/6
Forcefeild: Allowed 0/6
Autoegg: Allowed 0/6
AutoFish: Allowed 0/6
NoSwing: Blocked 6/6
NoSlowDown: Allowed 0/6 Score: 42/132
- X-ray statistics - Spy/Vanish system. - Easy-to view reports and alerts (SANE, without use of magic numbers or other silly stuff) - Auto-updating to keep everything working at all times. - Little to no configuration necessary. - A much, much easier API for developers to use. - Autobuild
In this test, I will play normal survival for 10min with each plugin. Anything over 10 will be considered false positive. False positives will have 5 points taken away. (10 for anticheat and 10VL for Nocheatplus due to different ratings)
False Positives:
AntiCheat:
There were no false postives for anticheat! The only sign was for fly for 1! Anticheat has been known to do lots of false positives. Since this was only 10min for solo survival, do not take a lot of input from this. This does the same for nocheatplus. +2
Nocheatplus:
There were no false positives for nocheatplus! There were a few violations that were at VL 3. +1
User Opinion:
After reading multiple forum posts, nocheatplus seemed to be the winner from users. +5
My opinion: After testing both plugins, I saw Nocheatplus blocking many things, while anticheat was having trouble blocking some things. I think nocheatplus is good for survival/faction servers to block most of the hacks. Anticheat seems to have some great features but having trouble blocking things that it is supposed to. I say Nocheatplus is the winner here. Suggestions for AntiCheat: Add more features and add more sensitivity for some hacks. Find a good balance.
Overall Anticheat isn't that bad. Just a few fixes. Leave a comment below on your opinion! Thanks for reading! If you have any plugin troubles feel free to PM or leave a comment! Thanks!!
Found a mistake? Make a comment below for me to fix or re-test!
I like nocheatplus because When i get on huzuni it wont let me do anything (i do that to test it) and also, nocheatplus was first nocheat, and was exactly like anticheat. Now they came out with a whole new one that completely blocks the noticable and soemthimes unnoticable things. So nocheatplus is the best!
There have been many topic asking peoples opinions on which they choose but, they don't test it. In this forum, I will be giving a fair test between Nocheatplus and Anticheat. In this test I will use Nodus 1.7.2 against Nocheatplus 3.10.12-RC-sMD5NET-b700 against Anticheat 2.0.2. I will be using a point system for the following aspects: Features, Blocking Hacks, False Positives, User Opinion. I will first test how Nocheatplus blocks hacks.
Fly: Blocked 6/6
Highjump: Blocked 6/6
Nofall: Blocked 6/6
Sneak: Blocked 6/6
Spider: Blocked 6/6
Sprint: Allowed 0/6
Step: Blocked 6/6
Water Walking: Blocked 6/6
AutoSign: Blocked 6/6
AutoTool: Allowed: 0/6
AutoMine: Allowed 0/6
FastBreak: Blocked 6/6
FastPlace: Allowed 0/6
Nuker: Blocked 6/6
BowAimbot: Allowed 0/6
ClickAimbot: Blocked 6/6
ForeField: Blocked 6/6
AutoEgg: Blocked 6/6
AutoFish: Allowed 0/6
NoSwing: Blocked 6/6
NoSlownDown: Partial 3/6
Score: 89/132
Freecam: Allowed 0/6
HighJump: Blocked 6/6
NoFall: Partial 1/6 (While jumping it thought I was flying and when I fell it only took away 1 heart)
Sneak: Allowed 0/6
Spider: Blocked 6/6
Sprint: Allowed 0/6
Step: Blocked 5/6 (First time I tried it allowed it)
Water Walking: Allowed 0/6
AutoSign: Allowed 0/6
AutoTool: Allowed 0/6
AutoMine: Allowed 0/6
FastBreak: Partial 4/6 (After multiple tries, I was able to break the blocks)
FastPlace: Blocked 6/6
Nuker: Partial 3/6
BowAimbot: Allowed 0/6
ClickAimbot: Allowed 0/6
Forcefeild: Allowed 0/6
Autoegg: Allowed 0/6
AutoFish: Allowed 0/6
NoSwing: Blocked 6/6
NoSlowDown: Allowed 0/6
Score: 42/132
- Spy/Vanish system.
- Easy-to view reports and alerts (SANE, without use of magic numbers or other silly stuff)
- Auto-updating to keep everything working at all times.
- Little to no configuration necessary.
- A much, much easier API for developers to use.
- Autobuild
There were no false postives for anticheat! The only sign was for fly for 1! Anticheat has been known to do lots of false positives. Since this was only 10min for solo survival, do not take a lot of input from this. This does the same for nocheatplus. +2
After reading multiple forum posts, nocheatplus seemed to be the winner from users. +5
My opinion: After testing both plugins, I saw Nocheatplus blocking many things, while anticheat was having trouble blocking some things. I think nocheatplus is good for survival/faction servers to block most of the hacks. Anticheat seems to have some great features but having trouble blocking things that it is supposed to. I say Nocheatplus is the winner here. Suggestions for AntiCheat: Add more features and add more sensitivity for some hacks. Find a good balance.
Overall Anticheat isn't that bad. Just a few fixes. Leave a comment below on your opinion! Thanks for reading! If you have any plugin troubles feel free to PM or leave a comment! Thanks!!
Check out my new account: http://www.minecraftforum.net/members/Captain__Obvious
Image Removed
My fan fiction of the game: http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1957118-programmer-my-first-fan-fiction/#entry24096758