Yeah, I think he'd be a terrible doctor. I mean, what does he have behind him? Absolutely nothing. And I thought I was asking to much to have David Tennant stay another season.
I wouldn't really enjoy it. It would just be odd seeing somebody that young as the doctor.
Toby is more of a goofy humor type of guy, whereas the doctor is more of a haunted goofy type. The doctor is still fun and enjoyable, but still shows a type of regret saying "This is your fault, it didn't have to end this way, I gave you the choice, and you chose this" to the suffering of his enemies.
I just don't think Toby would be able to pull off the serious part of the show.
I wouldn't really enjoy it. It would just be odd seeing somebody that young as the doctor.
Toby is more of a goofy humor type of guy, whereas the doctor is more of a haunted goofy type. The doctor is still fun and enjoyable, but still shows a type of regret saying "This is your fault, it didn't have to end this way, I gave you the choice, and you chose this" to the suffering of his enemies.
I just don't think Toby would be able to pull off the serious part of the show.
yeah your right now i think about it
right after something serious he would make a funny remark that wouldnt be funny at that time
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
2/17/2013
Posts:
145
Minecraft:
LCvideogamerP64
Xbox:
LCvideogamerP64
Member Details
Not British=Not Doctor. Hes not getting it because
1. As stated before, not British.
2. Hes not serious enough to get the role.
3. Not to offend anyone, but he doesn't seem smart enough to play as the doctor.
He has heaps of talent. I have no idea why you think you have any right to call him talent less. You're 14. You're young. You can't appreciate talent and Toby has a lot of it.
Just because he isn't your cup of tea (or mine either) you can't just say stuff like that. Imagine if you had millions of viewers watching your every move, expecting to be entertained daily via gameplay and in real life videos... It takes a man with some massive balls to do that.
Not just that, but I bet you have never, ever met him out of character. You don't know his personality. You don't know his acting. He could be a great Doctor but because of his public relations he simply can't be.
First thing I like about this is you immediately put my age into this. You're just saying how "I don't know enough about him" when you're just doing the exact same thing to me. Try not be a hypocrite when making a point.
The way he acts on camera is barely talent it's just him making different voices entertaining 9 year olds. Doctor Who is for a variety of ages and he just isn't the guy for it. You seem to really put My History into this which I find interesting for a person proving the point that I shouldn't judge him by his videos. Try again without the hypocritical parts.
Maybe give a decent argument that doesn't involve "He makes stupid voices" and because of it he can't act. You're just doing it again, saying that he has no talent. I mean, I think I have made fair points when all you do is repeat what you said before.
Come on. Really?
I could easily screen record my computer and play Minecraft for people whilst entertaining them. He might have talent, but he doesn't use it. I mean, he is funny, but he doesn't have talent.
Reasons he shouldn't be doctor:
1. He's not an actor, he's a gamer
2. He's not serious enough (as said before)
3. He isn't British (also said before)
He's obviously not cut out for the role of "The Doctor", but he isn't talentless. His talent just isn't really focused on acting.
Toby is a stand-up comedian. He is quite talented at coming up with humorous lines on the spot. He has a vlogging channel where he just films himself talking on his iPhone for a few minutes, updating his fans on things going on in the future. They can actually be quite humorous at times, considering he just wings it for every video and posts them daily.
On another note, Toby is a quite talented musician. He writes and plays all of his music by himself. Also in most of his songs he combines his comedy with his musical talent, and makes some pretty entertaining stuff. For example, his video "Dramatic Song". It's pretty cleverly written and amusing. (link )
You don't have to like his videos, or think they're funny, but to say he's talentless is just unreasonable. Almost 5,000,000 people have subscribed to him, and love his videos. It takes talent to accumulate an audience like that.
What your saying is the exact same for every other youtuber on the internet.
They all have vlogs. They all have songs. They all make jokes. They all have a huge subscriber base. (Note, Pewdiepie, Smosh)
They are there to entertain kids. Not Adults (and everyone else on the planet). None of you have seen him act so you can't go all fangirl and say he can even though you never seen him act.
And anyone can go on YouTube and make a funny series and get subscribers. It's not that hard. Go on YouTube and look at the top 100 channels. Majority of them are just them recording video games while the rest are them talking about funny videos or unboxings.
Maybe give a decent argument that doesn't involve "He makes stupid voices" and because of it he can't act. You're just doing it again, saying that he has no talent. I mean, I think I have made fair points when all you do is repeat what you said before.
Read more of my posts and you will see I say more than "He makes stupid voices"
I wasn't defending his acting ability, because to be honest it's not the best. There are two videos of him acting.
and
What I was saying is that he's not absolutely talentless. Just because other YouTubers have done similar things as him does not mean he doesn't have talent.
That's like saying someone who can play guitar well is talentless just because there are other people out there who can play guitar just as well.
If he can play the piano well, play the guitar well, and sing well, he has talent.
Said it doesn't take talent to become YouTube famous.
Playing a guitar, while is something, doesn't mean anything to being the 13th doctor. They don't play guitars.
Tobuscus is a terrible actor. He'd never make it 's where I discovered that he's a *terrible actor.*' class='bbc'>on TV, much less as arguably the most important interchangeable role in all of television.
1> He is actually an actor. He gets paid to act in all kinds of productions these days.
2> His CHARACTER on YouTube isn't serious enough, not him.
3> Can't argue with that.
Sorry, but I really don't care enough to read replies to this topic.
Toby is more of a goofy humor type of guy, whereas the doctor is more of a haunted goofy type. The doctor is still fun and enjoyable, but still shows a type of regret saying "This is your fault, it didn't have to end this way, I gave you the choice, and you chose this" to the suffering of his enemies.
I just don't think Toby would be able to pull off the serious part of the show.
That is just completely stupid to have him. He has no talent. All he does is use stupid voices to entertain 9 year olds.
yeah your right now i think about it
right after something serious he would make a funny remark that wouldnt be funny at that time
I do love Toby, his personality is cute and funny, but it wouldn't feel right if Toby got the role as the 13th Doctor.
1. As stated before, not British.
2. Hes not serious enough to get the role.
3. Not to offend anyone, but he doesn't seem smart enough to play as the doctor.
Overall, bring back Tennant.
First thing I like about this is you immediately put my age into this. You're just saying how "I don't know enough about him" when you're just doing the exact same thing to me. Try not be a hypocrite when making a point.
The way he acts on camera is barely talent it's just him making different voices entertaining 9 year olds. Doctor Who is for a variety of ages and he just isn't the guy for it. You seem to really put My History into this which I find interesting for a person proving the point that I shouldn't judge him by his videos. Try again without the hypocritical parts.
-MCForums
Come on. Really?
I could easily screen record my computer and play Minecraft for people whilst entertaining them. He might have talent, but he doesn't use it. I mean, he is funny, but he doesn't have talent.
Reasons he shouldn't be doctor:
1. He's not an actor, he's a gamer
2. He's not serious enough (as said before)
3. He isn't British (also said before)
Here be dragons
What your saying is the exact same for every other youtuber on the internet.
They all have vlogs. They all have songs. They all make jokes. They all have a huge subscriber base. (Note, Pewdiepie, Smosh)
They are there to entertain kids. Not Adults (and everyone else on the planet). None of you have seen him act so you can't go all fangirl and say he can even though you never seen him act.
And anyone can go on YouTube and make a funny series and get subscribers. It's not that hard. Go on YouTube and look at the top 100 channels. Majority of them are just them recording video games while the rest are them talking about funny videos or unboxings.
Talent =/= Subscribers.
Read more of my posts and you will see I say more than "He makes stupid voices"
Said it doesn't take talent to become YouTube famous.
Playing a guitar, while is something, doesn't mean anything to being the 13th doctor. They don't play guitars.
My DeviantArt
But, eh. I honestly couldn't see it, since the Doctor is actually serious at times. It'd be weird seeing him, well, serious.
David Tennant is Scottish as opposed to English. He's still British.
My DeviantArt
Obviously you do if your fighting against this.