I named it that cuz I can't think of a good title. And yes, it is my first suggestion.
This suggestion is about the villages.
Why defend villages with just kinda-expensive-to-make golems?
Why not you also defend your village with knights? That's right, knights!
They will wear the full iron armor set and use iron swords.
Hostile mobs will attack them though.
When a baby villagers grow up. There is a 25% They will become a knight.
Although knights will use iron swords. Some will use bows instead. You can find a knight holding a bow on the tower of churches. Sometimes 2 of them.
Also add this new structure in villages called horse yard.
Well it looks almost like a house. but with a medium-sized pen with atleast 2-3 horses. Well you can always get more horses into the pen!
There will will be 1 fence-gate.
Also sometimes. A knight will enter the horse pen, get a saddle place it on the horse and ride them (a saddle will just appear on their hands but the sword will disappear but when he places the saddle the sword will come back)
You can get their armor and weapon if you kill them but if there are any villagers who witnessed the murder. They will go to the nearest knight and the knight will try to kill you. But if a knight witnessed it they will start killing you right away.
If a knight rides a horse they can ride them into battle. There will be a few cases where the knights will just get off their horse.
Knights and golems won't kill eachother. They will just ignore eachother but if a knight is being attacked then the other knights or golems will come to aid the attacked knight.
Actually this ain't bad especially for a first idea. Though knights should be rarer. And its a bit redundent. But I wouldn't mind if this was introduced.
Half support.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
llamaglama, dunklestein and burningleaf777 are friends at school. Sometimes we all use the school computers. Please don't ban us for alt accounts.
I named it that cuz I can't think of a good title. And yes, it is my first suggestion.
This suggestion is about the villages.
Why defend villages with just kinda-expensive-to-make golems?
Why not you also defend your village with knights? That's right, knights!
They will wear the full iron armor set and use iron swords.
Hostile mobs will attack them though.
When a baby villagers grow up. There is a 25% They will become a knight.
Although knights will use iron swords. Some will use bows instead. You can find a knight holding a bow on the tower of churches. Sometimes 2 of them.
Also add this new structure in villages called horse yard.
Well it looks almost like a house. but with a medium-sized pen with atleast 2-3 horses. Well you can always get more horses into the pen!
There will will be 1 fence-gate.
Also sometimes. A knight will enter the horse pen, get a saddle place it on the horse and ride them (a saddle will just appear on their hands but the sword will disappear but when he places the saddle the sword will come back)
You can get their armor and weapon if you kill them but if there are any villagers who witnessed the murder. They will go to the nearest knight and the knight will try to kill you. But if a knight witnessed it they will start killing you right away.
If a knight rides a horse they can ride them into battle. There will be a few cases where the knights will just get off their horse.
Knights and golems won't kill eachother. They will just ignore eachother but if a knight is being attacked then the other knights or golems will come to aid the attacked knight.
Hope you likey my idea. c:
Good Concept, not realistic coding wise. This is minecraft, not Civ 5. You can have a mob-attack a certain mob. Thats it, nothing more. Can't you imagine a server having to do pathfinding to track a mob and have constant tick updates for this useless reason just because you want to see a movie happen with minecraft villagers? This suggestion isn't going to ever be put into the game, but might lead to something better maybe like a new mob that shoots arrows at zombies, and they might spawn near villages?
I named it that cuz I can't think of a good title. And yes, it is my first suggestion.
This suggestion is about the villages.
Why defend villages with just kinda-expensive-to-make golems?
Why not you also defend your village with knights? That's right, knights!
They will wear the full iron armor set and use iron swords.
Hostile mobs will attack them though.
When a baby villagers grow up. There is a 25% They will become a knight.
Although knights will use iron swords. Some will use bows instead. You can find a knight holding a bow on the tower of churches. Sometimes 2 of them.
Also add this new structure in villages called horse yard.
Well it looks almost like a house. but with a medium-sized pen with atleast 2-3 horses. Well you can always get more horses into the pen!
There will will be 1 fence-gate.
Also sometimes. A knight will enter the horse pen, get a saddle place it on the horse and ride them (a saddle will just appear on their hands but the sword will disappear but when he places the saddle the sword will come back)
You can get their armor and weapon if you kill them but if there are any villagers who witnessed the murder. They will go to the nearest knight and the knight will try to kill you. But if a knight witnessed it they will start killing you right away.
If a knight rides a horse they can ride them into battle. There will be a few cases where the knights will just get off their horse.
Knights and golems won't kill eachother. They will just ignore eachother but if a knight is being attacked then the other knights or golems will come to aid the attacked knight.
I actually think this is a great idea! Support, but I think the chance of a Villager becoming a Knight should be only 10% (you could cheat for iron armor and sword (or bow)).
I forgot to tell you how they look like without armor.
They're just villagers with the exception of folded arms. They will still have the big nose.
My rank says I'm Out of the Water. DOES THAT MEAN I WAS DROWNING THIS WHOLE TIME?!?! XD
1. Not funny, TBH.
2. Knights are honestly a terrible idea. "Hey let's have new villager protecters that you don't even need resources or a ton of villagers for" is basically what you were probably thinking. Iron Golems are powerful. Plus, with a villager breeder, you can easily get tons of golems (how do you think youtubers make iron farms?)
Give the kid some slack, sounds like he put a lot of thought into this.
Yeah about that. It doesn't "sound" like that at all. It looks like he just thought up a bunch of things on the spot and typed them out as he went - explaining very little of each idea. So no, it doesn't "sound" like that. P.S. This is still a wishlist.
As for the OP, I think having knights in villages is a cool idea. Just remember, sometimes simple is best.
I'm trying hard to not patronize you, but you are doing an absolutely horrible job at defending him. You thinking "knights are a cool idea" and "sometimes simple is best" doesn't prove anything.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The Unofficial Suggestion Guide - Everything you need to know to not make goofy mistakes in a suggestion! Honestly though, you should really go there.
Yeah about that. It doesn't "sound" like that at all. It looks like he just thought up a bunch of things on the spot and typed them out as he went - explaining very little of each idea. So no, it doesn't "sound" like that. P.S. This is still a wishlist.
I'm trying hard to not patronize you, but you are doing an absolutely horrible job at defending him. You thinking "knights are a cool idea" and "sometimes simple is best" doesn't prove anything.
Look fellas, he's obviously a young kid. He probably didn't read the stickies and also probably isn't aware of general forum ettiquette. I also wouldn't expect a kid to have the type of articulation a young adult would have.
The point is, nod your head and be on your way instead of filling threads with nothing but negative feedback. Everyone is fully aware this OP isn't well articulated or conformed to the sub-forum rules. You're not proving anything or making the community a better place by posting negative, condescending comments.
As for my comment about Knights being a cool idea, they are. And "simple is best" was just advice to the OP, it wasn't directed at you, user Theriasis.
Look fellas, he's obviously a young kid. He probably didn't read the stickies and also probably isn't aware of general forum ettiquette.
Well, he'll learn the hard way.
The point is, nod your head and be on your wa-
No. I think you should hold back on the whole headstrong "good cop" mentality for a bit. Don't tell other posters to "nod their head and be on their way". You might want to hold off flaring your chest out there like that. Negative responses will always happen no matter how sincere you are.
As for my comment about Knights being a cool idea, they are. And "simple is best" was just advice to the OP
Well no, it's just that you think knights are a good idea. Don't wrap your opinions in fact wrapping paper. Also, that "simple is best" is an absolutely horrible piece of advice to give on this forum. No, don't be short and simple, be detailed and well panned out. You don't seem to be in a spot where you can give good advice here yet...
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hey, you there. Yes, you! Are you thinking about posting a suggestion on the forums anytime soon? If so, please read this before doing so.
As for my comment about Knights being a cool idea, they are. And "simple is best" was just advice to the OP, it wasn't directed at you, user Theriasis.
Sorry to say this, but you're stomping on your own toes here. You are giving very bad advice to a new poster. Simple is best does not work here. When you make a thread, be as detailed as you possibly can so everyone understands your idea 110%. Don't be lazy and short with it.
Theriasis is also someone you probably never ever want to argue with. Just throwing that out there. The knights thing is just your opinion. Minecraft isn't an Elder Scrolls game.
Simple is best does not work here. When you make a thread, be as detailed as you possibly can so everyone understands your idea 110%. Don't be lazy and short with it.
I'm not sure you understand his meaning. "Simple is best", in the context he used it in, was most likely referring to the process of coding, not the making of a thread. Therefore; Simple idea -> Simple coding -> Quality mod , was more what he was getting at.
Saying "There is a mod for that" is still against the rules, but to clarify in a better way:
Existing Mod(s)
If a mod exists that provides part (or all) of the suggestions request linking to the mod is encouraged, however do not use the existence of a mod to dismiss the suggestion.
Knights are a cool idea - I think they should be the mini-soldiers of the Iron Golems, though it's already suggested before.
This suggestion is about the villages.
Why defend villages with just kinda-expensive-to-make golems?
Why not you also defend your village with knights? That's right, knights!
They will wear the full iron armor set and use iron swords.
Hostile mobs will attack them though.
When a baby villagers grow up. There is a 25% They will become a knight.
Although knights will use iron swords. Some will use bows instead. You can find a knight holding a bow on the tower of churches. Sometimes 2 of them.
Also add this new structure in villages called horse yard.
Well it looks almost like a house. but with a medium-sized pen with atleast 2-3 horses. Well you can always get more horses into the pen!
There will will be 1 fence-gate.
Also sometimes. A knight will enter the horse pen, get a saddle place it on the horse and ride them (a saddle will just appear on their hands but the sword will disappear but when he places the saddle the sword will come back)
You can get their armor and weapon if you kill them but if there are any villagers who witnessed the murder. They will go to the nearest knight and the knight will try to kill you. But if a knight witnessed it they will start killing you right away.
If a knight rides a horse they can ride them into battle. There will be a few cases where the knights will just get off their horse.
Knights and golems won't kill eachother. They will just ignore eachother but if a knight is being attacked then the other knights or golems will come to aid the attacked knight.
Hope you likey my idea. c:
Half support.
No Support.
Good Concept, not realistic coding wise. This is minecraft, not Civ 5. You can have a mob-attack a certain mob. Thats it, nothing more. Can't you imagine a server having to do pathfinding to track a mob and have constant tick updates for this useless reason just because you want to see a movie happen with minecraft villagers? This suggestion isn't going to ever be put into the game, but might lead to something better maybe like a new mob that shoots arrows at zombies, and they might spawn near villages?
The Unofficial Suggestion Guide - Everything you need to know to not make goofy mistakes in a suggestion! Honestly though, you should really go there.
Give the kid some slack, sounds like he put a lot of thought into this.
As for the OP, I think having knights in villages is a cool idea. Just remember, sometimes simple is best.
What did you think I meant?
There, now. That's really being the model MCF user! *back slap*
And yeah. Pretty fanciful idea, but a nice one, I suppose. I personally am just fine with Iron Golems.
They're just villagers with the exception of folded arms. They will still have the big nose.
My rank says I'm Out of the Water. DOES THAT MEAN I WAS DROWNING THIS WHOLE TIME?!?! XD
2. Knights are honestly a terrible idea. "Hey let's have new villager protecters that you don't even need resources or a ton of villagers for" is basically what you were probably thinking. Iron Golems are powerful. Plus, with a villager breeder, you can easily get tons of golems (how do you think youtubers make iron farms?)
Yeah about that. It doesn't "sound" like that at all. It looks like he just thought up a bunch of things on the spot and typed them out as he went - explaining very little of each idea. So no, it doesn't "sound" like that. P.S. This is still a wishlist.
I'm trying hard to not patronize you, but you are doing an absolutely horrible job at defending him. You thinking "knights are a cool idea" and "sometimes simple is best" doesn't prove anything.
The Unofficial Suggestion Guide - Everything you need to know to not make goofy mistakes in a suggestion! Honestly though, you should really go there.
Oh yes because a hastily written list of vague described ideas really shows his level of thought here.
I fixed this post for you. Also, the OP might want to check out these threads:
http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1968261-village-guards/
http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1152692-villager-warriors/
http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/914134-vilagers-fight-back/
http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/755626-turning-villagers-into-warriors/
http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1781775-adding-stables-and-grooms-to-npc-villages-12-supporters/
Want to play Minecraft SSP like Spaceboot1? Try my modpack, all mods made by me, Spaceboot1!
Look fellas, he's obviously a young kid. He probably didn't read the stickies and also probably isn't aware of general forum ettiquette. I also wouldn't expect a kid to have the type of articulation a young adult would have.
The point is, nod your head and be on your way instead of filling threads with nothing but negative feedback. Everyone is fully aware this OP isn't well articulated or conformed to the sub-forum rules. You're not proving anything or making the community a better place by posting negative, condescending comments.
As for my comment about Knights being a cool idea, they are. And "simple is best" was just advice to the OP, it wasn't directed at you, user Theriasis.
Well, he'll learn the hard way.
No. I think you should hold back on the whole headstrong "good cop" mentality for a bit. Don't tell other posters to "nod their head and be on their way". You might want to hold off flaring your chest out there like that. Negative responses will always happen no matter how sincere you are.
Well no, it's just that you think knights are a good idea. Don't wrap your opinions in fact wrapping paper. Also, that "simple is best" is an absolutely horrible piece of advice to give on this forum. No, don't be short and simple, be detailed and well panned out. You don't seem to be in a spot where you can give good advice here yet...
Sorry to say this, but you're stomping on your own toes here. You are giving very bad advice to a new poster. Simple is best does not work here. When you make a thread, be as detailed as you possibly can so everyone understands your idea 110%. Don't be lazy and short with it.
Theriasis is also someone you probably never ever want to argue with. Just throwing that out there. The knights thing is just your opinion. Minecraft isn't an Elder Scrolls game.
I'm not sure you understand his meaning. "Simple is best", in the context he used it in, was most likely referring to the process of coding, not the making of a thread. Therefore; Simple idea -> Simple coding -> Quality mod , was more what he was getting at.
Why is that?
Minecraft is whatever you want it to be. There is, in fact, a mod for that.
Saying "There is a mod for that" is still against the rules, but to clarify in a better way:
Existing Mod(s)
If a mod exists that provides part (or all) of the suggestions request linking to the mod is encouraged, however do not use the existence of a mod to dismiss the suggestion.
Knights are a cool idea - I think they should be the mini-soldiers of the Iron Golems, though it's already suggested before.